![Thanks](https://www.woodworkforums.com/dbtech/thanks/images/thanks.png)
![Likes](https://www.woodworkforums.com/dbtech/thanks/images/likes.png)
![Needs Pictures](https://www.woodworkforums.com/images/smilies/happy/photo4.gif)
![Picture(s) thanks](https://www.ubeaut.biz/wave.gif)
Results 1 to 5 of 5
-
25th February 2013, 03:22 PM #1
Member
- Join Date
- May 2007
- Location
- melbourne
- Posts
- 50
second hand boat stuff from a JW Tread Lightly - to destroy or not
hello all, have just come back from a weekends sail with my JW Tread Lightly trailer sailer.
I have not made up my mind, so this is hypothetical.
Boat needs some work, water got into the cabin, bottom stringers are discoloured, a little bit of paint lift off on cabin sole.
Is stringer discolourisation terminal, they are laminated stringers, so maybe it is just going along the surface. I can provide photos, stringers no doubt would be high quality rot resistant timbers based on the general very high quality of the overall build.
The other week I put a bung in the cockpit bilge floor and 12mm plywood floor there was perfectly dry, so maybe its the same further forward due to epoxy encapsulation. Also have damaged teh centerboard. cant tell if it is the fitting for the pin or if the board itself it warped. I guess this could be fixed with some work. This will not be an easy fix, but cant be super super super hard?
boat was very very well made initailly, high quality materials.
My issues is that the Tread Lightly (TL) is not a good boat in my opinion, the concept does not work.
Found it did not point high, first days sailing board would not deploy fully, only to about 45 degrees, meant to deploy deeper. Sails are low aspect ratio, cabin windage is high. Hull is short and beamy thus its never going to be fast. Upside is that it is very secure and very robust, handles rough conditions very well. Setup time took me 2 and a ahlf hours, as did packing away time. I know that with practice I can speed this up
Mast is a solid, heavy unstayed (there is also a mizzen). Plans call for a hollow mast, takes a lot of effort to raise, I can do it, but its not easy.
My issue is that it is trying to be a proper cabin sail boat with all the complications of heavy boat, trailering, launching, but without the internal space and speed of a larger trailer sailer. I would prefer a dingy cruiser.
So I am in 2 minds, I can fix up the boat and try and sell it or I can can chop up the boat and sell the fittings.
Things like 160kg of lead in 20kg ingots.
a 2hp Honda 4 stroke outboard
lots of stainless steel fittings (heaps and heaps and heaps)
a dunbier trailer
a very high quality large kickup rudder and tiller
a stainless steel bracket that goes on the transom that raises and lowers the outboard (kinda locks up and also locks down)
The outboard and outboard should be straight forward to sell.
The lead ingots, scrap metal are offering $200 but may get more from a boat builder
Is there much of a market for second hand stainless steel fittings.
what do people feel about the JW Treadlightly, yes it handles rough conditions very well, but so do other trailer sailers,
I can get a lot of photos, if required.
my main issue with fixing it up and trying to sell it, is that I am selling a boat that weighs a lot, is hence harder to launch, has relatively poor windward performance, is harder to store, but without the benefit of a big spacious cabin of a trailer sailer where you can sit down and have a cup of coffee etc. do you think such a boat would appeal to anyone. I know I will lose a lot of money either way, but dont think I can keep the boat, just does not do it for me. Why would anyone want a boat that takes 2 hours to get onto the water, you would have to be mad. Maybe with time setup is less. I guess if you lived close to the water you could leave it fully rigged? do such people exist?
what do boat builders pay for lead ingots, are 20kg lead ingots in demand? assume there are melted down, do they pay more than 1.20 a kilo that scrap metal dealer was offering.
I dont want this so sound like an add. if so I am happy to pay for all that, and do right thing and put it in appopiate forum, but at moment just unsure what to do. Is there something ethically wrong about chopping up a very well made boat because demand is limited
am stressed today -- just dont know what to do
-
25th February 2013 03:22 PM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Posts
- Many
-
2nd March 2013, 11:39 AM #2
Member
- Join Date
- Jun 2009
- Location
- Brisbane
- Posts
- 79
Hi Peter,
Hasten slowly.
Years ago I destroyed a wooden boat that was full of rot (A Hartley TS 18) and the second hand stuff was worth very little.( I still have some "might be handy oneday" bits). So dont destroy a sound boat because it didnt fit your needs.
Why wont the centerboard go right down? That will have a big affect on sailing ability, probably the main reason the boat doesnt go upwind too well, but if it still went upwind and was tackable then that is a plus, it means you can sail anywhere you want to go.
How did water get in? Leaks or spray/rain? If paint has lifted it will be easy to scrape off and see what timber is like underneath.
You have an issue with the mast, well all masts weigh a bit, and all small boat sailors get practice at the caber tossing thing. I have never seen a TL so I dont know how others do it, have you had a look at the Welsford builders group at Yahoo? jwbuilders : John Welsford Builders
The low aspect rig is how the boat is designed to work and doesnt necessarily mean low performance. Fix the centerboard first.
A boat with a bunk, galley, space to sit and have coffee will be much bigger and heavier than Tread Lightly and have a heavier mast and will still take an hour to set up and pull down plus launch and retrieve time. Have you considered a boomtent?
So dont make a rush decision.
Keep the boat under a tarp to keep the rain and birdshit out.
Have a practice rig / unrig at home to get the process sorted. KEEP LOOKOUT FOR POWER LINES.
Hope this is some help
Tom
-
2nd March 2013, 08:15 PM #3
Michael Storer tells a tale of one of his designs which wasn't built to plan.
It sailed like a dog.
Purely because of the "improvements" made by its builder.
Fix the known issues with your TL & review it.
Fix the centreboard.
Lighten the mast.
Sort out the connections between spars & mast.
Get someone familiar with the square sail to look at its cut & set.
It should point a lot better than you describe.
Maybe it still won't suit your requirements.
Sell it then as a going concern, & get something which does.
Or sell it now to someone who wants it & is willing to tweak it,
and get the boat you want.
my 2.2c worth.
AJ
-
3rd March 2013, 08:56 PM #4
Member
- Join Date
- Jun 2008
- Location
- Ipswich Qld
- Age
- 67
- Posts
- 94
Hi Peter,
I feel your pain- when something's not right it just changes your perspective.
I have looked at TL- over the years i've looked at hundreds of designs. its concept is a seaworthy cruiser for one and while the design seemed slow to take off, I understand it and its smaller sibling, SCAMP has now developed a following.
Welsford, like most designers develops boats for his local conditions- I gather these are high winds and some heavy seas.
I have a friend who build a beautiful Pathfinder, but its draft makes it a pain to sail in Moreton Bay, or the Pumicestone Passage, so it stays indoors most of the time and he's designed and built a series of boats more suited to his requirements. I have one of them.
There will be someone who wants your TL if you decide its not for you - however, as you rightly say, there is likely to be a financial loss involved- but sometimes that happens.
Have you spoken to the previous owner and or builder? Did you have a test sail when you bought it? There may be some tips to make rigging/unrigging easier and quicker- one of the advantages of a lug sail should be simplicity.
I assume the centreboard (off-centerboard?) is laminated ply? If so its fairly easily reproduced - removal and refitting may be more of a challenge. Did you get the plans with the boat?
The easy solution to a solid timber mast that's too heavy may be an aluminium one.
Poor performance from a balanced lug may be as simple as looking at the for/aft placement of the yard and luff tension. Look at Mik's articles on this subject and the you tube vidios on Ross Lillistone's site: re sail set up and controls on Phoenix 111.
In terms of water ingress and discolouration- it may pay to show it to a boat buider or restorer to get an opinion on exactly what's going on- or not.
Whatever you do- don't write it off and leave it to the elements. For example, trailers are very easy to sell, but if you do this you will severly limit your options.
I suggest you listen to tomtre and B.O.A.T and store it securely for a while and think about things when you've had a chance to put the whole situation into perspective.
Steve.Charter boat? What charter boat!?
-
4th March 2013, 02:58 AM #5
Member
- Join Date
- May 2007
- Location
- melbourne
- Posts
- 50
Just to keep all in the loop
I have repalced the trailer eletrics with sealed LED lights and new 5 core wiring, put the coupling higher, so thats fixed
I looked into an Al mast but after doing some maths, an unstayed Al mast comes out almost as heavy as a wood one, so no good going there, and stays dont really work on a lug sail. Looks like a Carbon mast at 2.3K dollars, main benefit is much lighter and easier to step. I weighed the mast and it comes out at 15.7kg. It does not sound a lot, but stepping it solo is hard work. Sounds a lot of money,,, but over 10 years. I will probably have to reinforce the bottom 5ft with some extra cloth (fiberglass/carbon), as a stayed mast is tapered, and carbon tubes are not. This allows me to use a narrower tube (cheaper and less windage)
Have seen blogs for 2 other TLs, got some ideas there.
One thing is to turn the anchor compartment into a buoyancy compartmnet (easy fix). Being shoal draught (beachable), the anchor is not used as much as other boats, so will wrap anchor in cloth and store under floor boards.
I worked out that the bottom yard of the lugsail is meant to be attached to the mast, this makes it more controllable, and I think moves the mainsail back a few inches, fixing the weather helm issue.
I think I have worked out how to fix the centerboard, I think it is the wood where the pin pivots in (need to replace that). Remove some screws and I should have access.
Other ideas, a few options really
i can fix up the boat and sell it
I can modify the boat
I want to remove the cabin (3 peices of ply and open it all up), make a big open boat like Scamp. Leave the cabin where it is but give it no back (just sides and top). The wood on the starboard side can go (opposite the board) - board is Port side, this will open the boat up more.
More floor boards so that the front of the boat is same level as cockpit floor (raise about 5 inches), I can store water, anchor under these boards.
Other ideas, increase top yard angle a bit (i have dacron and sail twine laying around).
Removing the 100kg of lead from where it is and moving it to the bottom of the skegs (I dont like where it is now). I need to melt down the ingots and make long narrow strips of lead to do this (use a concrete mold)-yucky job but not impossible
A removable cabin (not sure about this). But if I have no cabin forward I can get something that provides a lot more security. Not a super hard job, main downside with a cabin is more windage.
Boat did travel well reaching and in strong winds. Whatever I do, fixing the board and some little fixes are well worthwhile. Bigger fixes maybe. The prevoius owner has alzheimers and i bought it off his wife who did not know a lot.
I went to Yaringa today, they have space where I can do work on the boat for a few weeks for a modest amount of money. Idea is to go at it full time for a few weeks and then finish the job.
I think the rot is superficial (assume so), grind/sand it back then re-epoxy. I put in a bung under the cockpit and plywood was totally dry. (good news). What happened was that water got into the cockpit because tarpaulin did not cover it fully, then filled up and went into cabin. Thats why I put the bung in the boat, under the cockpit floor, so no water under the cockpit floor.
I am going overseas for a few weeks, so can go full time at these changes after that. Maybe I am daft, not sure. The overall concept as it is at present just does not work for me. It can be a steady sound daysailer of a boat (like Scamp) and sleep under canvas occasionally, that is fine, or it can have a cabin and be a microcruiser (but coastal,,, and nothing ..repeat nothing extreme,,, just when the weather is good).
Whatever happens, less weight up high, and more weight down low as a general rule cant hut. Stability is not bad, just want to have a bit more margin there.
I took some photos the other day, so can upload those plus some diagrams of what I intend to do in a while.
Apart from the mast, main downside is time (which I have plenty of at the moment)
Doing some basic fixes and selling it is an option, whether many people would be interested i dont know. Maybe with time setup time can be improved. The boat was able to go upwind just with no board (this is a plus). Also it self steers meaning that I almost fell asleep on second day. maybe poor upwind performane on first day was board not deploying fully. I do realise that i should have bought a capable dingy cruiser, but what is done is done
peter
Similar Threads
-
Will it destroy?
By Scott in forum NOTHING AT ALL TO DO WITH WOODWORKReplies: 11Last Post: 21st June 2011, 08:16 PM -
Hand crafted Timber Boat
By SimonP in forum CLASSIC BOAT RESCUE & ADOPTIONReplies: 0Last Post: 10th March 2011, 07:41 AM -
nails and stuff for the ski boat
By ibeanonchippy in forum BOAT BUILDING / REPAIRINGReplies: 3Last Post: 29th January 2009, 06:58 AM -
Second hand stuff I scored
By JDarvall in forum HAND TOOLS - UNPOWEREDReplies: 25Last Post: 21st August 2007, 05:32 PM -
Lightly used Disston saw ...
By Green Woodchips in forum HAND TOOLS - UNPOWEREDReplies: 1Last Post: 13th September 2005, 05:52 PM