View Poll Results: In your opinion what flute profile does this P&N bowl gouge have?
- Voters
- 15. You may not vote on this poll
-
U profile
5 33.33% -
V profile
9 60.00% -
Hybrid
1 6.67%
-
4th October 2017, 09:10 AM #16SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Location
- Brisbane (Macleay Is)
- Posts
- 271
Neil thanks again for your replies
My first observation was that your Crown Ellsworth gouges have a much wider open flute than the Woodcut perhaps even wider/ open than the Superflute. Do you notice any difference in the wings or how they cut.
The second was that you are using a diamond wheel. I thought (perhaps wrongly) that the general advice was that diamond wheels were not generally recommended for woodturning gouges because of the brittleness of diamonds and their tendacy to shatter and breakdown. One of the reasons that CBN was introduced was because of their toughness
I really appreciate the grinding improvement that occured when I changed to a 180grit CBN from Al oxide but still find the 180 CBN a bit coarse and agressive so was considering a finer CBN for a second wheel. Also considered changing to a slow speed grinder for same reasons.
Maybe I should consider a diamond wheel instead.
Any advice?
Cheers Ron
-
4th October 2017 09:10 AM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Posts
- Many
-
4th October 2017, 04:44 PM #17
The flute profile on the Woodcut is very similar to the bowl gouge profile in Peter Child's 1970s book, see image followng... so has good pedigree...
The way I turn is to sharpen all of my bowl gouges in batch mode and use them one after the other as each becomes blunt. I can't say that I have notice much difference between any of them other than the Henry Taylor Superflute that has that very wide parabolic flute. It takes a different grind to the others on my standard swept back grind jig setting. It does a good job on the inside of bowls (like a U flute) so I mainly use it for that.
You can see the different grind in the following two photos; the HT is on the right and on the top in the second photo. The wings are shorter.
And, here is the Woodcut (on left and bottom) alongside the HT S-f, both 1/2".
As you can see they are very similar and I don't notice any significant difference between the two in use. If anything, the Woodcut holds an edge for longer.
All I can say is that I have been using my diamond wheel constantly for years now and it has had minimal loss of grit and at the rate I am wearing it down I expect to keep using it for many years yet.
Unless you are expecting to sharpen tungsten I would go for a higher grit CBN wheel if you want a higher grit finish. The price of CBN wheels has come down nowadays and they are very good.
I'm not convinced there is any advantage with slower speed grinding on HSS. Different matter if you are grinding high carbon steel blades.Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
4th October 2017, 04:58 PM #18
Apologies (on behalf of the Forum software) for the missing images in that last post.... FIXED NOW, had to upload them again!
Yes, a PITB. It has been very temperamental today! The images were there in preview but not when I posted.Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
4th October 2017, 07:33 PM #19Senior Member
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
- Location
- New Zealand
- Posts
- 186
It has not done that much work really. I bought a 16mm and a 10mm at the same time, they both sat unused for 15 years. The 16mm in the photo is dirty from roughing out some green bowls last weekend. I will give it a sharpen and post another photo so the profile is clearer.
I sharpen with a Woodcut Tru Grind jig on an 8 inch 220 grit CBN wheel. The grind is 45 degrees on setting 2 for the arm. I can't remember what the original P&N grind was but I think the wings are swept back a bit more. I have an old Teknatool 12mm bowl gouge ground at 55 degrees straight across and it is brilliant for the bottoms of bowls.
Michael
-
5th October 2017, 02:52 PM #20
I went back to check on the history of the Superflute and the following webpage chronicles Roy Child's development of it.
http://www.peterchild.co.uk/info1/sflute.htm
So:
- The parabolic (my use of term) flute profile predates the Superflute and was initially forged in high carbon steel. See example from Peter Child's 1970s book in my posting above.
- Roy Child developed the profile that was to be later called the Superflute and that was first made by Peter Child & Son and ground and tempered in high carbon steel.
- Henry Taylor took over the manufacture of it in M2 HSS and called it the Superflute.
- After this the U flute profile, which is a cheaper profile to manufacture, started to be made by various tool makers. Confusingly, it became known as the 'traditional profile'.
- The V profile became yet another later development.
Before purpose-made hand forged bowl gouges we turners adapted gouges that were primarily used for spindle work and made more extensive use of scrapers. I started turning in the late sixties and I can say that any bowl gouge of any profile that you can buy now is better that what we had then!Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
5th April 2018, 03:51 PM #21
Vicmarc bowl gouge
I am adding a Vicmarc bowl gouge to my arsenal. Just arrived today.
Their site describes it as having a parabolic flute profile. My reading of it is that it is closer to having a catenary profile (with a= ~2) than parabolic, but that is a moot point. See earlier posts for the small difference.
For comparisons, its profile is close to that of the Henry Taylor Superflute and Woodcut gouges, profiles that I like.
As received, the following images are of the gouge from end on, top down and oblique view. Also included is a detail photo of the surface grind.
VM - grind end view - sm.jpgVM - grind top view.jpg
VM - pre-grind - sm.jpg VM - flute grind - sm.jpg
I have some opinions about the gouge before using it, but I will reserve any comments until I have modified the grind to my preferred profile and used it.Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
5th April 2018, 05:20 PM #22SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Location
- Brisbane (Macleay Is)
- Posts
- 271
High Neil
Waiting to hear your impressions on the Vicmarc gouge. Do you know what type of steel they are made of?Was intrigued by your last cryptic comment.
Ron
-
5th April 2018, 08:01 PM #23
The finish of the VicMarc flute looks a bit rough. Or is that just the pic? To me it looks like you'll need to do a fair bit of polishing in the flute before you'll manage a reliable edge. (Maybe they bought out some P&N stock? )
Personally, I tend to simplify things. Gouges that are pressed from flat stock I label U-flutes. If the flute is milled into solid stock, that's a V-flute. I've yet to see a stamped gouge with a V-flute and I can't think of any milled gouges with U-flutes.
They both probably exist, but I don't own any. Which is fine with me. Keeps my life simple.
That's always best. I do like the pressed U-flutes for roughing work but they're sharpened with minimal wings so I can rotate the tool while roughing to 'find fresh edge.'
For final shaping and finishing I've developed my own grind. Basically an ellsworth 'done wrong,' but it works very nicely for me. Unfortunately, it doesn't take much change in the flute profile to make 'my' grind unsuitable so I've sort of backed myself into a corner when it comes to buying new tools to grind to that profile.
Must be time to unlearn some bad habits and re-generalise my skill set...
- Andy Mc
-
5th April 2018, 08:51 PM #24SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Location
- Brisbane (Macleay Is)
- Posts
- 271
Skew
Since when have HSS gouges been pressed from flat stock?
-
6th April 2018, 09:38 AM #25
You've never had a chaiwanese HSS-stamped gouge blue semi-unexpectedly while sharpening and then behave exactly as low grade CS from then on?
Still, you ask a fair question. As I said prior, I don't have any milled gouges with a U-flute. Some come quite close but on close inspection are actually a catenary curve, hence are V-flutes to me.
- Andy Mc
-
6th April 2018, 10:01 AM #26
Yes, Andy, it looks rougher than what you would get as a finish on many makes of gouges, but perhaps not quite as rough as the P&Ns. About the same as the Thompsons. I'm yet to polish the flute so won't know how deep those milling/grinding marks are until I've done that. The only flutes I've never had to polish are the D-way (absolutely beautiful flute finish on those) and the Henry Taylor Superflutes. I'll report back on how it went when I've given the end of the flute a polish.
Ron, VM say that the steel they are using is Vandis 10 (see below), also known in the USA as A11. Doug Thompson also uses V10 steel. It's a powdered metal with about 10% vanadium. Doug does a "triple temper with a cryogenic treatment between the first and second temper".
I don't know what VM does on the tempering. Vanadis 10 is a Swedish steel made by Uddeholm. Here is their description:
UDDEHOLM VANADIS® 10 SUPERCLEAN
Uddeholm Vanadis 10 SuperClean is a high vanadium alloyed powder metallurgy tool steel offering a unique combination of an excellent abrasive wear resistance in combination with a good chipping resistance. It is manufactured according to the powder metallurgy process giving a very low amount of non-metallic inclusions.In tool making Uddeholm Vanadis 10 SuperClean offers a good machinability and grindability together with a good dimensional stability during heat treatment. It can normally be hardened to 60–65 HRC.Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
6th April 2018, 11:59 AM #27
I gave the VM bowl gouge a test run with the grind as supplied and, as expected, it was not to my liking.
Keeping in mind that the grind that comes on a new gouge is just a starting point. The makers pick a middle of the road grind that is quick and easy for them to manufacture and the user modifies it from there to suit themselves. The only gouges that came close to my preferred grind as supplied are the Thompsons and I think the reason for that is that Doug Thompson follows the Jerry Glaser 'grind profile guidelines' (more on that later), which I also like.
So, I reground the VM to my preferred grind. The photo on the left is of the grind as supplied. The one on the right has been reground to my preferred grind for this flute profile, except for the 'cheek' of original grind left on the sides, which will diminish with future re-sharpenings. No need to waste steel unnecessarily!
As you can see the new grind gives a sweeter convex curved edge that is more in keeping with its parabolic/catenary flute cross section. I found that the reground VM performed much better on the inside of some bowls, where I find the grind is most critical. Almost any grind will work on the outside of bowls with the bevel rubbing.
Note: Your experience and preferred grind may be very different from mine. Mine may not work for you, but for what it is worth to anyone I will explain more about my preferred grind in a separate posting or thread later.
More comments to come.Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
6th April 2018, 12:19 PM #28GOLD MEMBER
- Join Date
- Sep 2008
- Location
- North Carolina, USA
- Posts
- 2,327
Most interesting and informative thread. Thanks to all.
So much timber, so little time.
Paul
-
6th April 2018, 01:36 PM #29
Should have mentioned that the remaining thickness of the steel at the bottom of the flute on this VM (5/8" bowl gouge) is about 6.5mm.
In comparison with other gouges with a similar flute profile, this is on the thicker side with the Henry Taylor having 5.5mm and the Woodcut 7mm. I should also measure the Ellsworth signature gouge that has a very open parabolic/catenary flute to see how that compares with the others.
I mention this as I find that this variation in thickness does have some effect on how the bevel rubs through the 'transition area' inside a bowl.Stay sharp and stay safe!
Neil
-
6th April 2018, 02:42 PM #30SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Location
- Brisbane (Macleay Is)
- Posts
- 271
Hi Neil
Thanks for the updates.
Two Q if I may.
You have obviously tried quite a few different bowl gouges. Do you have any views on which steel produces the sharpest edge and which has the longest lasting edge.
Secondly I have recently purchased the Hannes sharpening jig which if used like recommended produces a very narrow primary bevel and a rounded off heel. Have you tried this type of grind?
Cheers
Ron
Similar Threads
-
Hand taper pin reamers, spiral flute v straight flute
By bob ward in forum METALWORK FORUMReplies: 11Last Post: 22nd July 2014, 09:30 PM -
The best fingernail profile bowl gouge?
By Chief Tiff in forum WOODTURNING - GENERALReplies: 25Last Post: 6th August 2010, 02:43 PM -
Flute first
By Scally in forum WOODWORK PICSReplies: 1Last Post: 27th July 2009, 08:43 AM -
Deep flute gouge
By thefixer in forum WOODTURNING - GENERALReplies: 5Last Post: 16th April 2009, 10:33 AM -
Never send a spindle gouge to do a roughing gouge's work
By Tristan Croll in forum WOODTURNING - GENERALReplies: 6Last Post: 23rd June 2003, 09:59 AM