Dion N
20th August 2004, 05:40 PM
I'm looking to replace my Triton Workcentre and planer attachment (thus alienating most of the Triton fanatics! :D ) with some sort of table saw (possibly the Dyco woodworker as I'm also interested in a jointer, but I don't really need the router as I intend on keeping the Triton router table). At present, I'm looking to develop a set of criteria to measure various saws against. So far, I'm come up with the following:
1. Weight and Portability - It has to share the garage with a router table, bench and motorbike! So I guess that it will have to be a contractor style as opposed to a cabinet saw. I have a mobile lifestyle so the removalists have to be able to move it!
2. Accuracy (primarily the ripping fence) What should I be looking for here?
3. Induction Motor (don't want to annoy the neighbours!) What is the noise difference like compared to a non-induction sawbench motor?
4. Ripping Capacity / (maybe the ability to cut panel/sheets at a later stage ie can I retro fit some sort of sliding carriage at a later stage?) Preferably up 45 degree titlting arbour
5.Dust Extraction - 'nuff said
6. Cutting Capacity - I am thinking 10" is the way to go
7. Cost<$1000 ( somewhat negotiable)
8. Durability/Quality - the Chief Designer insists that I get a saw that will last a lifetime (or at least the next twenty years - she has said that this is the last "upgrade" permitted!.... :( we'll see... ;) )
The saw is going to be used for the next few years to build weekend projects (some cabinetry, slab furniture) and then a house in 5-10 years time.
With all that in mind, I would like to know if anyone has any suggestions for a saw that might fit the criteria above.
A quick perusal of the Timbecon and Carbatec catalogues made me think that the following saws might be suitable
Carbatec
Delta 10" Contractors Saw DE-36-650
Carbatec TJZ10G
Carbatec MJ2325B
Carbatec CT-10ST (sliding saw - not sure what slides here, maybe the left extension table slides?)
Also - Carbatec has a Scheppach 10" circular saw bench with a small sliding table and panel cutting attachment, but the top is galvanised steel as opposed to cast iron - is this a problem for accuracy?
At Timbecon, the Sherwood MJ2325 looks OK.
Any and all advice welcome!!
PS - I can't afford a Jet, so please no gloating over how good your Jet is!
1. Weight and Portability - It has to share the garage with a router table, bench and motorbike! So I guess that it will have to be a contractor style as opposed to a cabinet saw. I have a mobile lifestyle so the removalists have to be able to move it!
2. Accuracy (primarily the ripping fence) What should I be looking for here?
3. Induction Motor (don't want to annoy the neighbours!) What is the noise difference like compared to a non-induction sawbench motor?
4. Ripping Capacity / (maybe the ability to cut panel/sheets at a later stage ie can I retro fit some sort of sliding carriage at a later stage?) Preferably up 45 degree titlting arbour
5.Dust Extraction - 'nuff said
6. Cutting Capacity - I am thinking 10" is the way to go
7. Cost<$1000 ( somewhat negotiable)
8. Durability/Quality - the Chief Designer insists that I get a saw that will last a lifetime (or at least the next twenty years - she has said that this is the last "upgrade" permitted!.... :( we'll see... ;) )
The saw is going to be used for the next few years to build weekend projects (some cabinetry, slab furniture) and then a house in 5-10 years time.
With all that in mind, I would like to know if anyone has any suggestions for a saw that might fit the criteria above.
A quick perusal of the Timbecon and Carbatec catalogues made me think that the following saws might be suitable
Carbatec
Delta 10" Contractors Saw DE-36-650
Carbatec TJZ10G
Carbatec MJ2325B
Carbatec CT-10ST (sliding saw - not sure what slides here, maybe the left extension table slides?)
Also - Carbatec has a Scheppach 10" circular saw bench with a small sliding table and panel cutting attachment, but the top is galvanised steel as opposed to cast iron - is this a problem for accuracy?
At Timbecon, the Sherwood MJ2325 looks OK.
Any and all advice welcome!!
PS - I can't afford a Jet, so please no gloating over how good your Jet is!