Upside down sharpening

[Poloris]

One of the inventions shown on Wednesdays New Inventors was a upside down honing jig.
It was made by Perth man Peter Collins and cost $450.00.
Not my cup of tea.
But if your interested in having a look you can download the episode(40).

http://www.abc.net.au/tv/newinventors/video/video.htm

Poloris

[Cliff Rogers]

I've seen blokes sharpen their scrapers upside down to get a better wire edge, I tried it & it works for some things but... I'm one of the weirder types who sometimes hones a scraper too.

[les88]

Australian Wood Review #56 magazine page 83 has an advert for the Sharpening Guide for the inventor
les

[munruben]

At $450.00 I think I will give it a miss.

[Toolin Around]

Hell at a 90mb download I'm not that interested in even looking at what it is. Anyone want to post a pic.

[Groggy]

There was one of these on the HNT Gordon stand at TwwwShow in Melbourne recently. I didn't see it operate but it looked well made.

[Pat]

Maybe we need Dean to have look at it?:)

[DJ’s Timber]

There is a review of it in Australian Wood Review no 55 on page 16 with a picture

[TommyC]

I saw a demo at the melbs WWW show, and yeah, seems pricey.

[China]

Not for me

[kman-oz]

I saw it in action and the Melb WW Show too, it *looks* well made. Certainly a lot of thought and effort have gone into it's design and construction, but, I see several short comings that could easily have been addressed in a better design.

And lets face it, for $450 I'll have a grinder, stones, lapping plate, Veritas honing guide and, I believe, a better result. Credit for a very interesting alternative, but not for me.

[ftje]

I spoke to the guy at the show and was actually quite impressed wit how sharp his tools were. you could literally shave with them. i looked at the blade and used it.. then he sharpened it and the difference was awesome...

However, the price he was asking was quite steep. i'm not sure if i'd pay that much for it.

[silentC]

I think it has limited potential for sharpening gouges. Anything flat, it's definitely not worth the money when you can achieve the same results using a normal honing guide. There's something about having a razor sharp edge mounted upside down and exposed that I don't like.

[Ruddy]

I saw the show and my reaction was that for $450 it was impossible to justify. IMHO that is way too expensive.