Thread: Choosing a Thicknesser (DeWalt, Carbatec, Timbecon)

Thanks twosheds

I made up a quick and dirty planer sled on the weekend, to use with the thicknesser when it arrives. Can't wait to start the next project!

Originally Posted by crowie

I purchase a secondhand 2hp Jet from a forum member!
It works very well with the blower on the Dewalt

Here’s your photo of my Jet Dust Collector, it's at the entry to the garage but on wheels for moving outside if need be.

I wish I had the room to do a small dust collector shed outside the garage...

D15BE5A8-34C1-443D-9346-BE6349E3FAE8.jpg


PS - Did you have a look at the link to market place I sent you for the dewalt?

Originally Posted by aussieadam

Thanks twosheds

I made up a quick and dirty planer sled on the weekend, to use with the thicknesser when it arrives. Can't wait to start the next project!

Which one did you go for?

Originally Posted by crowie

Here’s your photo of my Jet Dust Collector

D15BE5A8-34C1-443D-9346-BE6349E3FAE8.jpg


PS - Did you have a look at the link to market place I sent you for the dewalt?

Wow, that's much more than I can fit into my tiny garage, unfortunately. I have to come up with a dust extraction solution asap. Might get this, and just clamp it onto the end of the exhaust

POWERTEC Filter Bag Small Dust Collector Replacement Woodworking Tool 3 Micron 711181985719 | eBay

I did look at that marketplace one, and I'm glad pics were posted. In the end, the Mrs decided to go with a new item. Mainly for the warranty. This is a new type of tool for me, so would like the peace of mind of warranty.

Originally Posted by Treecycle

Which one did you go for?

90% leaning towards the DeWalt, so long as I can figure out a dust extraction solution. I called DeWalt this morning to see if I could attach my vac (below), but was told no.
DEWALT 1400W 38L Construction Dust Extractor M Class DWV902MXE | Total Tools

I've got the DeWalt and it is a nice, sturdy machine. The results are really good (if the blades are) so I didn't see the need for a spiral cutter head. The only drawback is that it makes a hell of a noise, so I use it only occasionally. I don't want to get in trouble with my neighbors who are really tolerant to my hobby so far. I consider putting up brick walls around my workshop to ease the noise a bit for them.
The DeWalt has a 100 mm outlet, so I use it with the Carbatec dust extractor.

The Dewalt has a built in blower so I would have thought you could use one of those filter bags you linked to and maybe not need a dust extractor.
Have a look at this vid to see how it works.

Originally Posted by AndyJ

I've got the DeWalt and it is a nice, sturdy machine. The results are really good (if the blades are) so I didn't see the need for a spiral cutter head. The only drawback is that it makes a hell of a noise, so I use it only occasionally. I don't want to get in trouble with my neighbors who are really tolerant to my hobby so far. I consider putting up brick walls around my workshop to ease the noise a bit for them.
The DeWalt has a 100 mm outlet, so I use it with the Carbatec dust extractor.

The noise is my worry as well. Hoping I can use it during the week on my lunch breaks, seeing as I'm working from home for the immediate future.

Originally Posted by Treecycle

The Dewalt has a built in blower so I would have thought you could use one of those filter bags you linked to and maybe not need a dust extractor.
Have a look at this vid to see how it works.

Perfect, just what I wanted to see I'll get that dust bag and some PVC from Bunnings. Thanks!

I found the original 3 blade Dewalt heaps quieter than my older 2 blade unit I has previously.

BUT when I did the upgrade with the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead; WOW, quieter than the neighbours lawn mower!!
Extra bonus; the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead gives a hand smooth finish every time.

Originally Posted by crowie

I found the original 3 blade Dewalt heaps quieter than my older 2 blade unit I has previously.

BUT when I did the upgrade with the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead; WOW, quieter than the neighbours lawn mower!!
Extra bonus; the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead gives a hand smooth finish every time.

I considered buying one of these; however the reviews aren't really that good: Amazon.com.auustomer reviews: Byrd Tool Shelix cutterhead for Dewalt planer DW735

Especially the bad reviews are very detailed.

What is your experience with that product?

G’day Andy,
I can’t fault the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead
I’ve had it in my Dewalt DW735 a good 4 of 5yrs and hasn’t missed a beat.
I haven’t even had to rotated any of the cutting segments.
I put hundreds of metres of old reclaimed hardwood though it.
It’s quiet enough to have conversation with someone while it cleans up the old timber.
The finish is pretty well hand smooth every time.
While it wasn’t the cheapest option I recommended it to all who ask.
If you live close enough you’re welcome to come and try it.
That my review for what it’s worth, but IMHO, I can’t fault it!
Cheers crowie

Originally Posted by crowie

G’day Andy,
I can’t fault the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead
I’ve had it in my Dewalt DW735 a good 4 of 5yrs and hasn’t missed a beat.
I haven’t even had to rotated any of the cutting segments.
I put hundreds of metres of old reclaimed hardwood though it.
It’s quiet enough to have conversation with someone while it cleans up the old timber.
The finish is pretty well hand smooth every time.
While it wasn’t the cheapest option I recommended it to all who ask.
If you live close enough you’re welcome to come and try it.
That my review for what it’s worth, but IMHO, I can’t fault it!
Cheers crowie

Hi Crowie

Did you get the OEM version or the original (reduced sized) for the 735?

SHELIX for DEWALT 13'' Planer, DW-735 (shelixheads.com)

Just so I know for future.

Cheers!

I bought mine from Robert at Woodcraft Supplies whom I met at the Sydney Woodwork Shop back in 2012/2013


I think the following info is the part number description for the kit??


Byrd Tool Corp :: SHELIX :: SHELIX JOURNAL HEADS ::

46.8mmCC 13.05"CL 15.65"OAL SHELIX WITH BEARINGS

DEWALT DW-735 - Details - SKU #P131518B

SHELIX

I've been following this thread and was a little surprised how favorable it came down to the dewalt plus adding the Shelix head. it is a great machine...

I'd got sidetracked on utube one night and watched the original version of this guys experience installing the new head and he has just released version2
I'd call this a must watch...... The video I wish I watched before buying a Shelix (video version 2) - YouTube

He actually bought a second machine to do a side by side comparison of the OEM v undersize version.

Lot's of good info and worth the time out of your life

Cheers
Phil

Originally Posted by crowie

G’day Andy,
I can’t fault the Byrd Shelix Cutterhead
I’ve had it in my Dewalt DW735 a good 4 of 5yrs and hasn’t missed a beat.
I haven’t even had to rotated any of the cutting segments.
I put hundreds of metres of old reclaimed hardwood though it.
It’s quiet enough to have conversation with someone while it cleans up the old timber.
The finish is pretty well hand smooth every time.
While it wasn’t the cheapest option I recommended it to all who ask.
If you live close enough you’re welcome to come and try it.
That my review for what it’s worth, but IMHO, I can’t fault it!
Cheers crowie

I have the same set up and fully concur with Crowie, couldn't be happier with the Dewalt/Byrd and am glad I spent the extra $$$.

Cheers,

Rudy