Thanks: 0
Needs Pictures: 0
Picture(s) thanks: 0
Results 1 to 12 of 12
-
8th July 2019, 01:21 PM #1Senior Member
- Join Date
- Oct 2018
- Location
- Melbourne
- Posts
- 128
Upgrade to a spiral head, or buy two separate machines?
Folks,
I have a legacy Carbatec AW106PT (now called TJ-250P) - a 10" combo jointer/thicknesser. I'm generally quite impressed with the unit, although some of the harder and longer timber I process can be tricky - tear-outs, sniping, etc. Changing between modes is also a minor bugbear.
I could upgrade my existing unit to a true spiral helix head for ~$700, which would put my total cost of ownership at a pretty reasonable amount. Alternatively, I could put the money towards buying a separate machine (either jointer or thicky) with traditional knives, to avoid having to switch machine modes.
I guess what I'm asking is: whether the benefit provided by the shelix head would outweigh the minor inconvenience of having to switch machine modes all the time.
Thanks in advance
-
8th July 2019 01:21 PM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Posts
- Many
-
8th July 2019, 06:36 PM #2Taking a break
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Location
- Melbourne
- Age
- 34
- Posts
- 6,127
-
8th July 2019, 08:40 PM #3SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- May 2013
- Location
- Auckland, New Zealand
- Posts
- 997
I have a combi and I have sprial cutter block on mine, If I had space and money I would gone for separate. but combi you do get the benefit of 2 machine into 1. I cant justify spending $$$ on a 500mm wide jointer, cos I rarely need it. but when I do, its really handy.
To me, the spiral cutter block is more important than switching modes. besides, I dont have space anyway.
- - - Updated - - -
I have a combi and I have sprial cutter block on mine, If I had space and money I would gone for separate. but combi you do get the benefit of 2 machine into 1. I cant justify spending $$$ on a 500mm wide jointer, cos I rarely need it. but when I do, its really handy.
To me, the spiral cutter block is more important than switching modes. besides, I dont have space anyway.SCM L'Invincibile si X, SCM L'Invincibile S7, SCM TI 145EP, SCM Sandya Win 630, Masterwood OMB1V, Meber 600, Delta RJ42, Nederman S750, Chicago Pneumatics CPRS10500, Ceccato CDX12
-
8th July 2019, 10:21 PM #4Senior Member
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
- Location
- Newcastle
- Posts
- 337
I have a jet 260mm combo machine like yours with straight knives. There is no way I would ever retrofit a helical into it because (a) I have already got a cutter head in the machine and I couldn’t sell it, only scrap it (b) there are better things to do with my time than stuff around trying to install it and it needs to be very precisely aligned to the outfeed table because the insert knives are fixed, not set to the outfeed each time (c) there are many things I’d rather spend the money on in the workshop with more benefit
I don’t care much about having straight knives at the moment because I use a drum sander after planing for the face side of my boards...a drum sander is an amazing tool and can do several things a spiral head thicknesser can’t (sand, flatten wide panels and slabs, sand veneer to precise thickness etc) with no snipe and no tear out (no matter the grain direction.
If I were you I would definitely save the $700 and put it into a drum sander rather than spiral or separates. If in the future you want or need to buy a bigger combo like a 310, I would recommend getting it with a helical head at purchase.
-
8th July 2019, 10:25 PM #5Senior Member
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
- Location
- Newcastle
- Posts
- 337
Duplicate post
-
8th July 2019, 11:29 PM #6
Ditto - I considered converting my JET JPT310 to a helical cutterhead. Mine is the old straight blade type, because the HH version didn't exist back then. Would have been well over $1000 (and that was years ago), but I bought a JET 16-32 drum sander instead. One of my better decisions.
MUCH more useful; there are still some timbers and grain combos that a helical head can't handle well (burl??), but a drum sander does everything. Especially good for creating thin sections for laminating, sanding wide panels, you name it.
-
9th July 2019, 08:02 AM #7Senior Member
- Join Date
- Jan 2017
- Location
- Sunshine Coast
- Age
- 64
- Posts
- 212
I think it depends on the type of work you do. I have a combi unit with straight knives, and a drum sander.
For my money, finish is the real issue. The sooner I can get the level of finish you desire the happier I am.
For my money (if I had it), spiral blades would get me there quicker, with less effort.
But, like i said, it depends on what you do/make with your machinery.
Caveat. I have a magnetic gauge base, dial gauges etc, and I still hate changing/adjusting straight blades. I mean I really hate it.
Another reason my money would go towards a spiral head.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
9th July 2019, 12:07 PM #8SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Nov 2010
- Location
- Perth W.A
- Posts
- 720
I have Carbatec 10x8 combination machine, Chinese made, including the spiral head. The finish from this machine is near flawless but changeover to and from thicknessing mode is a real pain as the bed has to be wound down to 130mm when changing back to surfacing mode to allow the chip collector to swing back under the machine.
My thicknessing work is done on a 15" Carbatec thicknesser with a "spiral"head but not a true spiral head as in the combination machine and this one leaves grooves in the finish which require sanding out by ROS or drum sander.
I would never go back to straight knives despite the cost of the inserts for the spiral heads, even though changing them is tedious but simple.
My combination machine uses radiused inserts and the 15" machine are straight.
I did track down the manufaturer of my spiral head on Alibaba some years back so chinese manufactured spiral heads can be very good if you can find a good supplier.
-
9th July 2019, 01:57 PM #9Novice
- Join Date
- Jul 2012
- Location
- perth
- Posts
- 23
Ideally having a dedicated machine for specific tasks would be the preferred option but it also adds to the maintenance cost, additional cleaning, space and another concern would be dust control. The main thing for me would be the last two points mentioned, having to allow space and material feed for two machines and additional routing for dust control....if you go down the dedicated route.
-
10th July 2019, 03:04 PM #10
FWIW I've got an electra beckum. I believe some of the other 10" combos are copies of this design. I love mine and it takes minutes to switch.
Problems:
Setting the knives properly after sharpening. Blessed nuisance. This is probably the biggest reason I'd look at a spiral head.
Tearout and snipe. You can minimise it but it will always be a problem with knives.
Ribbon "chips" clog everything I've tried to use to catch them. Blessed bother. So a third good reason to go spiral.
graham.murfett above hits the nail on the head. Depends on your circumstances. I spend whole days running boards through my machine. Plane for ages then thickness. If you have the luxury of organising yourself that way a combo is wonderful. For those occasions when 10" isn't enough there is the router sled. I absolutely could not justify the cost or space for separate machines. So far I've put off the upgrade, but I keep it very much in mind.
2c.I'm just a startled bunny in the headlights of life. L.J. Young.
We live in a free country. We have freedom of choice. You can choose to agree with me, or you can choose to be wrong.
Wait! No one told you your government was a sitcom?
-
15th July 2019, 08:41 PM #11
very hard to look past spiral heads with regards to finish cut ,would have to be a serious consideration.
Johnno
Everyone has a photographic memory, some just don't have film.
-
16th July 2019, 06:59 AM #12GOLD MEMBER
- Join Date
- Jun 2014
- Location
- Seattle, Washington, USA
- Posts
- 1,857
Ugh, this is a horrible decision to have to make! Is there some kind of third option where you stick it out with what you have now, clip coupons, mow some lawns, sell chopping boards at the local market, and buy the two machines with spiral cutters?
One thing I'd worry about is losing width. If you switch to two machines, you're likely to end up with a wider thicknesser but a more narrow jointer. That's a shame.
Have you considered just upgrading your combo machine altogether so that you can get one with a helical cutter block but which is also wider and designed for easier changing between techniques? The Hammer machines (A3-31 and A3-41) are supposed to be the proverbial bee's knees.
At the very least I'd try to maintain the same width of cut on the jointer. I think you'll miss those two inches if you downsize to an 8".
Cheers,
Luke
Similar Threads
-
Hammer A3 41 Spiral Head
By warmtone in forum JOINTERS, MOULDERS, THICKNESSERS, ETCReplies: 14Last Post: 19th April 2019, 04:10 PM -
Spiral head retrofit to old NZ/AUS machines
By WoodyNZ in forum JOINTERS, MOULDERS, THICKNESSERS, ETCReplies: 11Last Post: 7th December 2017, 09:14 PM -
Spiral Head conversion
By royflatmate in forum JOINTERS, MOULDERS, THICKNESSERS, ETCReplies: 43Last Post: 21st September 2017, 09:53 AM -
separate machines vs combinations
By MrRob in forum HAND TOOLS - POWEREDReplies: 10Last Post: 7th September 2004, 04:17 PM