Needs Pictures: 0
Picture(s) thanks: 0
Results 31 to 44 of 44
Thread: Table Saw or Router?
-
18th April 2020, 12:22 PM #31I mean I agree with his views but they're from a certain vantage and sometimes he way overshoots your average garage woodworker.
He is also in business, and he is a salesman. It is necessary to recognise the sales pitch coming and when he is deliberately selling himself. Often he is quite down-to-earth, but there are time when he is OTT. You should see the latest method for transferring tails to pins in his dovetail lessons. Talk about training wheels ... That, however, is his audience.
When it comes to choosing machines on YouTube, his was the only video I could find (easily, that is ... I did not do an exhaustive search) which looked at the priority of purchase. I respect his opinion here. Many others I would not as they are not makers. What did strike me about his choices was that he did not mention routers or a router table. He owns and uses them, so the extrapolation is that they are not in his top 4 machines.
Given the goal is to build boxes, which is what the OP notes, the table saw would be the most useful machine. It is relevant that the edges sawn are finished smooth, A bandsaw cannot do that. It is important that boards can be flattened and thicknessed. A handplane and thicknesser can do this. A small combination jointer-thicknesser would be better. Dust collection does not seem exciting as it is not an obviously productive tool, but it becomes essential once you begin using machines. Anything you do with a router table can be done with hand planes, and without dust (I have done so for decades .. although I do have a router table). Then, again, someone coming from a background of machines-only will not think the same way ...
I’ve kept an eye on this thread since I find the topic interesting - how all plan and organise their approach to building.
Regards from Perth
DerekVisit www.inthewoodshop.com for tutorials on constructing handtools, handtool reviews, and my trials and tribulations with furniture builds.
-
18th April 2020 12:22 PM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Posts
- Many
-
21st April 2020, 09:13 AM #32GOLD MEMBER
- Join Date
- Oct 2018
- Location
- Dandenong Ranges
- Posts
- 1,892
Hi Capt. C. I am wondering if you need any more input but I will jump in anyway . I think a tablesaw would be the most versatile investment. With jigs (particularly a cross cut sled) you can acheive most woodworking tasks. I used a jigsaw for many years for cutting curves and my tablesaw blade can cut almost 90mm above the table. Flip the board end to end and I can resaw a 170mm board, which is the resaw capacity of my bandsaw anyway. Also while you may have some projects in mind now, things will change as your interests and abilities develop. The more specific the purpose of a tool is , the less it can grow with you.
Derek, I am always amazed at the number of machines that seem to be normal in Nth American workshops, DIY and professional.
-
22nd April 2020, 01:14 AM #33Visit www.inthewoodshop.com for tutorials on constructing handtools, handtool reviews, and my trials and tribulations with furniture builds.
-
22nd April 2020, 09:24 AM #34SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
- Sydney
- Posts
- 749
This system will work with ANY circular saw and also routers. It's very versatile.
Bora edge Search Results
-
22nd April 2020, 10:24 AM #35GOLD MEMBER
- Join Date
- Mar 2015
- Location
- Melbourne, Vic, Australia
- Posts
- 1,255
As I've been working in the shop the last few days, I have been thinking about the bandsaw vs tablesaw issue. The truth is I wouldn't want to be without either one! However, for the way that I work, I would still give up the table-saw before the band-saw if I could only keep one. I find myself often re-sawing boards from thicker rough stock into thinner boards and also cutting tenon cheeks and even ripping longer or thicker pieces on the bandsaw in preference to the table saw.
I think the advantages of a high-quality band-saw are - less space claim which may be significant in a small shop, allows you re-saw thicker boards (I personally wouldn't even feel comfortable re-sawing a longer piece with 90mm of 3.2mm table saw blade) which I find I do a lot for every project and prefer to buy larger pieces of rough-sawn timber, allows you to cut tenons easily and accurately, creates far less dust when paired with even a lower-end dust collector, allows you to cut curves, allows for easy parting of a box/lid if you are into box making and also resawing small / thin pieces like internal dividers etc. It's also safer than a table saw.
The down-sides are that you will have to finish with a hand-plane as the bandsaw will leave some marks etc (but so does a table saw a lot of the time - just not as bad) and that the table saw makes breaking down flat stock much quicker and easier than using a track-saw or similar.
Not an easy decision though and one I'd definitely prefer not to have to make.
Cheers,
Dom
-
22nd April 2020, 11:36 AM #36SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- May 2013
- Location
- Auckland, New Zealand
- Posts
- 997
given the constraint of space, I say go with a quality bandsaw, and a jointer/planer combo.
tablesaw? I had one for 2 years, and upgraded to a sliding panel saw. its useful but when you constraint with space, no table saw is fine.
When I upgraded to a panel saw I also sold my compound mitre saw.
I didnt have a router until 7-8 years into woodworking, and I had a spindle moulder before owning a router.
The limited work space is the primary killer of any workshop.SCM L'Invincibile si X, SCM L'Invincibile S7, SCM TI 145EP, SCM Sandya Win 630, Masterwood OMB1V, Meber 600, Delta RJ42, Nederman S750, Chicago Pneumatics CPRS10500, Ceccato CDX12
-
22nd April 2020, 07:45 PM #37Awaiting Email Confirmation
- Join Date
- Apr 2020
- Location
- Aldinga Beach, South Australia
- Posts
- 37
-
23rd April 2020, 11:15 AM #38SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
- Sydney
- Posts
- 749
My pleasure - it seems that the "NGX" rails are the new & improved ones. The router attachment works on both rail systems.
BTW, they also have a jigsaw attachment, but I've never really understood why you would want to make a straight cut with a jigsaw if you can use a circular saw! maybe someone can enlighten us!!
-
23rd April 2020, 12:09 PM #39
I wholeheartedly agree. I HATE re-sawing using a tablesaw. I've got a good tablesaw (Sawstop PCS) so the power is no issue, but it always feels sketchy and like a bad idea. Since I got my bandsaw (second hand lowest common denominator type), about 90% of its use is re-sawing. And although the finish is far from good it just feels so much safer. Perhaps I'm doing something wrong with the tablesaw, but have no desire to going back to re-sawing on it.
-
23rd April 2020, 01:00 PM #40
Lance, that you can re-saw on the tablesaw is not a recommendation to do so. There are many tools which are like Swiss Army Knives, but no one would recommend them because of this.
The bandsaw excels at re-sawing. Or curves. It is not recommended for dimensioning, whether ripping or crosscutting ... unless you are also prepared to do further finishing work, such as planing or sanding. Even the best re-saw blade I have leaves mill marks.
The major tool of choice for the OP - and many here keep ignoring this point - needs to dimension boards for boxes. A bandsaw is not the best choice here. A tablesaw is. The tablesaw can leave dimensioned pieces that do not need any further finishing, other than minor polishing (sanding or hand planing).
Leave re-sawing to a bandsaw. I made a lot of solid wood pieces for a few decades with a tablesaw, and only purchased a bandsaw when I was ready to re-saw. Jointing and thicknessing was done with hand planes up until that time. the alternative to the latter is a combo jointer-thicknesser. If proficient with hand planes, I'd get a jointer (it becomes easier to thickness when one side is flat). If not, then get a thicknesser, and use it with a sled to joint as well.
But the bandsaw is way down the list for me if I was the OP.
Regards from Perth
DerekVisit www.inthewoodshop.com for tutorials on constructing handtools, handtool reviews, and my trials and tribulations with furniture builds.
-
23rd April 2020, 01:30 PM #41SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
- Sydney
- Posts
- 749
OK - given what you have and what you plan to do AND space constraints - I think this would be a good plan:
1. A band saw. You can re-saw timber for your boxes, small table parts and night stands etc. You can cut to length, rip to width, you can cut joinery such as tenons and you can cut curves if you want to get adventurous with things like cabriole legs. For all these projects, you are going to want to finish these with other tools anyway. While a table saw will allow you to cut parallel (using the fence) and square (using a sled) you can achieve these outcomes in other ways. If you buy the Bora track system (or make one) you can accurately & safely break down sheet goods if that is needed. You can square up small parts easily using a hand plane (you say you have hand tools) and a shooting board. This will readily accommodate box making and many other parts needed in furniture making. You can mill flat & to thickness using a thickness planer (see point 2) or learn to do this using hand planes. Thickness planer would be the best bet here IMHO.
2. As others have said, this should be considered very high on your list, unless you want to develop hand tool skills & joint & thickness with planes. However, even many dedicated hand tool enthusiasts forgo the grunt work of dimensioning by hand & use a thicknesser. You can also use the thicknesser to joint edges & you can mill a board parallel if you use the appropriate jig. See my post here for some jigs that you can use: Carbatec 8 inch bench top jointer
3. A router is very versatile. If you get that Bora track system, you can use it to accurately cut dados & grooves for furniture. In a table (which is easy to make - there are MANY online plans & instructions) you can safely cut rabbets for your box making & furniture projects, along with many other tasks.
If you DO decide you want a tablesaw & space really is an issue, a good quality job-site saw that comes with an integrated fold up stand might be the best answer.
The SawStop is very well built & has the added benefit of its safety features. It folds up & takes minimal space when not in use
See: SawStop Jobsite Saw Pro JSS Pro 2019 Model | Carbatec
The Bosch GTX 10SC & can come bundled with a stand. It gets good reviews from people who own it, and has the advantage of having a sliding table built in
Se: 255mm (10″) Table Saw GTS10XC + Stand GTA60W (0615990HA6) by Bosch – Beyond Tools
-
23rd April 2020, 02:56 PM #42
Thanks for clarifying. I read it as an endorsement of the method.
I guess we're interpreting "making boxes" with lenses specific to our experience, of which I acknowledge you have significantly more! Rather than cause any further confusion, I will talk about my experience, and the process I went through as a beginner.
When I hear boxes, I think of something generally no larger than a shoe box, and shall we say "dainty". This discounts under bed toy boxes etc.
I see two main dimensioning jobs for boxes, stock thickness and parallel long edges. The short edges are easy enough to manage with a square, hand saw and shooting board, so won't address them here.
The first is getting the correct thickness. I dislike making boxes with 18mm thick sides, as I think it has an overly chunky look, and thinner stock isn't readily available (though I admit to never putting much effort into searching it out). This is especially true with special timbers for lids where thick stock is a waste of expensive timber. As such pretty much every box I have made ends up with stock being re-sawn. I used to do that on the table saw . When I finally got a bandsaw it was much better (well that's not entirely true as it took me a while to work out how to get it tuned properly). For this, a bandsaw works exceptionally well, as you noted. Mine is cheep and nasty, and requires several passes over the face with a plane to remove machine marks, but it is safe and quick.
The second is ripping the parallel walls of the box sides, lid and base. Once I managed to get my bandsaw set up well enough to re-saw consistently, I find that I can also rip against a fence without any drift from parallel. The edge surface finish isn't fantastic, but a couple of passes with a plane and they're as good as any finished surface from the tablesaw.
So thinking back, had I not wanted the ability to re-saw stock, a table saw would have been the right choice. For what I was doing however I would have been better served with a tuned bandsaw and hand plane. I do acknowledge however that success with this setup is predicated on being able to tune the bandsaw, and learn how to use and sharpen a hand plane. To some that would sound like an exciting learning opportunity, whist to others an impediment to just making boxes.
I hope that helps explain my rationale. There may well be good arguments that point out the error of my ways, of which I'm always happy to hear and learn from.
-
23rd April 2020, 09:30 PM #43
Lance, the one thing that this thread demonstrates so clearly to me is that there is no single way to approach building boxes or furniture. Everyone has their own idea about how to do things, and which machines or tools they prefer to use in the process.
And that's the way it should be. Of course life would be simpler if everyone just agreed with me, but that is asking a tad too much. Or so my wife and the dog tell me every day
Actually, I think that this has been a really interesting thread in this respect. No one is right or wrong. That's how we learn from each other.
Do you think that we have driven the poor OP to drink?
Regards from Perth
DerekVisit www.inthewoodshop.com for tutorials on constructing handtools, handtool reviews, and my trials and tribulations with furniture builds.
-
24th April 2020, 01:21 PM #44
This seems similar to the accurip of Kregs. I wonder if this could be a cheaper reliable slightly/closer to accurate way replacement for a plunger if you're strapped for cash?
Novice woodworker (hopefully) here guys. Take it easy on me.
- - - Updated - - -
In regards to the Bora tools comment above...
This seems similar to the accurip of Kregs. I wonder if this could be a cheaper reliable slightly/closer to accurate way replacement for a plunger if you're strapped for cash?
Novice woodworker (hopefully) here guys. Take it easy on me.
Similar Threads
-
Plunge router for router table with above-table adjustments?
By Old Hilly in forum ROUTING FORUMReplies: 27Last Post: 6th February 2019, 08:31 AM -
Triton Router table RTA300 VS Carba-Tec Cast Iron Top Router Table
By pellcorp in forum TRITON / GMCReplies: 17Last Post: 30th April 2009, 02:43 PM -
What is a good router table/router table accessories?
By SilverSniper in forum ROUTING FORUMReplies: 22Last Post: 4th March 2009, 10:05 AM