Thread: 2 V 3HP routers

I have a Scheer 3hp router that accommodates 70mm raised panel cutters without any problems, I don't think I would want to go much lower in hp, for production in my opinion a spindle moulder would be a much better option.

2hp can probably handle it; I have run 3" diameter panel raising bits (the bearing version of this 2 Flute - Raised Panel Bit - Carbide Tipped - Carbitool ) by hand with a 1700w fixed speed Hitachi in US Oak and Walnut with no issue. I don't think the extra 200w is make-or-break, just need to listen to the motor and adjust the feed to prevent it getting bogged down.

It's a good excuse to upgrade and probably a good idea, but not strictly necessary.

EDIT: Obviously a moulder would be best, but that's a MUCH bigger investment and certainly not practical for most DIY users

I think the key to this question is in the "production" aspect. I don't suppose for one moment we are talking thousands, but even twenty or thirty is enough to warrant more attention.

For thousands, at least a spindle moulder is the order of the day. but more likely a dedicated moulding machine with multiple cutters. For twenty or thirty I would expect to use the largest router I could access within reason, bench mounted and with variable speed. As the cutter diameter increases the speed should be reduced to maintain an optimum peripheral speed.

I note that Elan used a hand held, fixed speed machine but he has huge experience in this area. I would not recommend that most of us try this. I would also suggest it was not his first choice of operation. The potential for a large cutter to grab and cause damage is more than I am willing to risk both to the work and myself. So for me a large HP router with variable speed control, mounted under the table is the way to go.

Regards
Paul

PS. If only a smaller machine is available, that is acceptable. You just have to feed the material more slowly.