Thanks: 0
Likes: 0
Needs Pictures: 0
Picture(s) thanks: 0
Results 1 to 15 of 21
Thread: Do I need a Left Handed Bench?
-
23rd July 2009, 10:44 PM #1Novice
- Join Date
- May 2003
- Location
- Merrylands, Sydney
- Posts
- 21
Do I need a Left Handed Bench?
I built my first bench about 12 years ago when I knew nothing about what I wanted it for, and it has served me well, however it's time to build a "real" bench and fix all those things I did incorrectly due to ignorance.
Now for the hard part.
I regard myself as left handed, though not exclusively so. I write left handed, but swing a cricket bat right handed, throw lefty, cut with scissors righty - all probably due to the way I was taught to cut/bat etc. This all probably explains why I can't write neatly, and never did get that call to open the batting and bowling for Australia.
When it comes to some tools I'm just unsure what left and right handedness mean - With some it's obvious - I use a hammer, saw and and pliers with my left hand and a screwdriver in either (but that could be because there is better mechanical advantage in screwing in with my right hand). When paring with a chisel I hold the body of the chisel with my right, with my left near the head doing most of the work. Most importantly I use a jack plane with my left hand at the front, right hand at the back - therefore work right to left on a long board (but I don't know if this is right or left handed)
Now the point of all this. I know that traditionally on a "right handed" bench the face vice is at the left and the tail vice at the right, and plenty of comments to do it the other way around for lefties.
What I want to know is
- why this is the case
- what tools make this an advantage for the right hander and therefore a disadvantage for the left hander
I'm only getting one shot at building this bench and I want to get it right. I need to make the decision on left vs right handed design, but can't yet see the compelling reason why I should go either way.
What's the consensus out there on the practical reason for the traditional LH/RH design?-----------------------------------------------
Oh that was easy said God
And went on to prove that Black is White
And got killed at the next Zebra Crossing
-
23rd July 2009 10:44 PM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Posts
- Many
-
23rd July 2009, 10:49 PM #2
Most of my benches have always had the vice on the left.
My current bench has the vice on the right, it didn't take me long to get used to it.
So my 2 cents worth is that it doesn't really matter which end the vice is on.
-
23rd July 2009, 10:52 PM #3
Don't know, my bench is ex SA schools and had a vise on each long side of the bench so that 2 students could work on the (wider than normal) bench.
I took the back one off and mounted it on the front, so I have a left and a right vise.
I use whichever is appropriate although I use the right one more than the left one. The left one has a metal vise clamped in it most of the time.
Having 2 vises is very handy for long boards as well.
-
23rd July 2009, 10:53 PM #4
I can relate to much of what you said. I'm a lefty with 2 older brothers - both righthanded, so am right-handed in most sports, left handed the rest of the time.
Back to your question about the bench. The way you describe holding a plane is definitely right-handed, so I'd expect placing the vice in a right-handed configuration would work best for you.
-
23rd July 2009, 11:27 PM #5
Lefty Vs Righty
Just to add another few cents worth. I have built a couple of benches over time and have always put the vice on the right with out even thinking about it. Then after seeing other peoples benches relised that they predominently had theirs on the left......I don't know why I chose the right (when I am Mainly right handed) its just what you get used to.
For holding long stuff there are drawers under the bench which I just pull out to support the long board. Depending on the depth of the long piece depends on whether I pull out the top middle or bottom drawer.
I would just go with what feels comfortable for YOU (it is your bench!)
-
23rd July 2009, 11:48 PM #6
I was told that you mount the vice on the left for right handed people so when you are cross cutting for length (docking) using your right hand to hold the saw your left is available to support and remove the offcut so it does not fall and tear.
I am right handed but play all two handed sports left handed and ride any board goofy foot (left). Never considered that I may plane or chisel anything other than right handed. I hold a plane tote in my right hand when planing and when paring hold the handle of the chisel in my right hand and guide with my left up near the cutting edge, is this how true righties do it?
-
24th July 2009, 09:58 AM #7
Hi Flinchy,
Im also left handed. I have, by necessity, like the others, learned to do things right handed. I think you should try and have a go at a few configuratons (perhaps at Carba Tec or the like) before you decide because you may be able do a lot of operations right or left handed.
Im embarking on a bench project as well and would like to see what you come up with."We must never become callous. When we experience the conflicts ever more deeply we are living in truth. The quiet conscience is an invention of the devil." - Albert Schweizer
My blog. http://theupanddownblog.blogspot.com
-
24th July 2009, 03:46 PM #8
It is mostly how you will be planeing. All the other things can mostly be done anywhere on the bench. You can hedge the bet and have a vice either side.
-
24th July 2009, 04:00 PM #9
Putting a vice at both ends of your bench will limit the length of board you can clamp to the distance between the vices - unless it is a narrow board in which case you can clamp in both.
Typically, you would clamp a board in the vice, resting the other end on a dead man or a pulled out drawer or whatever, and you would plane towards the vice. So if you plane with the rear handle in your right hand, you will want the vice to your left.
In your case, I would probably set the bench up right handed.
I bought an old bench off a bloke a few years ago. He was left handed and had put the shoulder vice on the right hand end of the bench. He commented to me that he always felt he had made it back to front. I told him that it was actually a left handed bench, which made him raise his eyebrows a bit. So I guess he planed right handed like you do."I don't practice what I preach because I'm not the kind of person I'm preaching to."
-
24th July 2009, 04:07 PM #10
If your bench is an island and not up against a wall you could put either two vices on one side (at each end) or one on each side of the same end allowing you to work both left and right should you so wish. Sounds like it might be a good idea for you if you swap hands depending on tool use.
-
1st August 2009, 02:45 PM #11
I am looking at designing my own workbench and I am left handed.
I have been, experimenting, with standing left, and right on the bench.
I have come to conclusion, that while, I am able to to work with my right side of my body against the bench, while paring, and planing. However I feel that the having the right side of my body against the bench, as being just a little uncomfortable, as if I am twisted, and that the bench is pocking me. Where if I stand with the bench on my left hand side, I do not have twisted felling.
I never realized how left handed I was until I started making hand tools. I made them and they were extremely comfortable. Yet I watch right handers fumble with my tools, because they just cannot get a grip on the tool, because the tools were back to front.
I am therefore placing my vice on the right side, so that I can have me left side against the bench.
-
1st August 2009, 03:01 PM #12
And to really throw the cat among the pidgeons...
I have my vise on the right end and maybe about 400mm or so from the end of the bench, for the reason that when I am jointing boards I often stand diagonal to the corner of the bench. Of course it depends on the length of the stock to where I position my body.
Everyone is going to have their own way, and none of the opinions are wrong. I'd visit a few blokes and see how you go working at their benches with different configurations and as Sebastiaan56 wrote, maybe visit C/Tec and see what works best.
-
1st August 2009, 06:32 PM #13
You might just try planing 'left handed' for a bit - left hand on the back handle. Might feel awkward at first, but based on your other preferences I suspect you'd settle into it pretty easily and quickly come to prefer it.
Then it's an easy decision to build a left handed bence with the front vice on the right and tail vice on the left.
Tex
-
24th June 2012, 08:13 PM #14
Hi all
I thought I'd reactivate an old thread rather than start a new one.
I am a lefty, and am well advanced in planning a roubo style workbench. Tradition says that for a right hander, the face vice should be on the left, and the tail vice on the right. For lefties, this is the reverse.
I am a pretty normal lefty - left hand on the back tote of the plane, left hand on the handle of the chisel, and saw with the left too. I can see the logic in a face vice on the right, as I can plane towards the vice, not away. And I can saw past the right hand edge of the bench, holding the off cut as I go.
What I don't get is the tail vice. Is the idea that, by putting it on the LHS, I plan towards the middle of the bench? I think it would be better to plane from the middle out, not the end in.
Any thoughts on this?
TravSome days we are the flies; some days we are the windscreen
-
25th June 2012, 01:06 AM #15
Trav,
The use depends upon the type and configuration of your tail vise.
My understanding and experience is that the tail vise is there as an alternate means of holding stock not easily or practically held by hold-downs or the face vise.
For example, when smoothing the faces of boards or panels. You use the dogs in your bench and a dog (or dogs) in the tail vice to grip the board or panel. This way you can work the panel or board both toward the centre of your bench and up toward the face vise without catching your clothing or anatomy on the face vise.
It's also a good way to hold stock when shooting mouldings, as the thinner stock can be fully supported by the bench and is not subject to flex.
I've also used a tail vise to help with glue-ups. Clamps can bow and distort some forms but the tail vise and appropriately placed weights can tame the twists and bends
If you look through a few YouTube videos or the benchcrafted site you'll get the idea.
Horaldic
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
Similar Threads
-
Left Handed Bandsaw
By ravlord13 in forum BANDSAWSReplies: 3Last Post: 17th May 2008, 12:12 AM -
Left handed measuring tape ????
By govarney in forum WOODWORK - GENERALReplies: 12Last Post: 20th April 2008, 10:46 PM -
Left Handed Circular Saw
By Eagle in forum HAND TOOLS - POWEREDReplies: 37Last Post: 19th June 2006, 03:07 PM -
Left handed tools
By tonyhart in forum HAND TOOLS - POWEREDReplies: 31Last Post: 14th June 2005, 03:15 AM -
Are you Left or Right Handed?
By Tankstand in forum POLLSReplies: 39Last Post: 4th June 2005, 08:16 PM