Thread: The Great War by Les Carlyon

I haven't read this book yet although I plan to.

My wife gave me the book Somme Mud for Christmas which is a firsthand account of the fighting in France and Belgium from 1916 to 1918 by an Australian digger.

If you have an interest in WWI and particularly the Australian involvement, it is well worth a read.

Yes I agree Craig, Somme Mud is a fantastic read. I would have loved to read a less edited version of his journals though, even if its a lofty enough tome as it is.
I will keep an eye out for Les Carlyons book.

I was given 'The Great War' at Christmas. It is nearing the top of my reading 'to do's and am looking forward to it as it received good reviews.

I was given a copy of Carlyons book for Christmas and think its a great read, how the Aussies did what they did is amazing.
I also have most of the returned servicemans books published by the Australian War Memorial. These are written by servicemen & women, often the humour reminds me of Australia as it was when I was growing up, a very different time & place.
I dont have any of these from WW1, although I keep an eye out for them I have never seen a copy of the 4 titles published.
Grateful if someone can put me on to them.
Regards, Bill.

Another two great reads in the same genre are Tobruk and Kokoda by Peter Fitzsimons. I found both very hard to put down.
Cheers
Graeme

Haven't read Fitzsimmons offerings but WRT the New Guinea campaign, try reading "A Bastard of a Place". It's a pretty good insight into the campaign I reckon.

Read it and you'll ask yourself why you don't know the name of General Potts.

You'll also ask yourself why you weren't ever taught at school about Milne Bay. The first ever land defeat of Japanese forces in WWII.

Originally Posted by craigb

You'll also ask yourself why you weren't ever taught at school about Milne Bay. The first ever land defeat of Japanese forces in WWII.

Or any other Australian History since 1890 ( the lead up to Federation ) or any of our war's history.
All the Aussie history I learnt was after I left school, its a shame but most Australial kids can name more US presidents than they can Australian Prime Ministers, and god forbid if you ask them the first Prime Ministers name

Such was our school system not only when I was there in the dark ages but when my Daughters were there as well.

Rgds

Originally Posted by craigb

Haven't read Fitzsimmons offerings but WRT the New Guinea campaign, try reading "A Bastard of a Place". It's a pretty good insight into the campaign I reckon.

Read it and you'll ask yourself why you don't know the name of General Potts.

You'll also ask yourself why you weren't ever taught at school about Milne Bay. The first ever land defeat of Japanese forces in WWII.

You mean General Macarthurs great victory don't you?

The mother of an ex of mine had her great uncle's diary from WWI. He was sent to France, was only 16 or 17 when he enlisted. It's just mind blowing to read the matter of fact way he describes the things that went on. Watching his mates getting wiped out left right and centre and just commenting on it like he's watching cars go by: "John killed this morning by a grenade. Bill lost a leg. Bit unlucky. Got a letter from Mum. No biscuits this time."

He ended up getting gassed. Put him in the hospital for a few months. The treatment sounded pretty horrific. Something about putting a wire in the corner of his eye for some reason, didn't really understand that. Then they sent him back. He got gassed again, worse this time, so they sent him home.

After the war he made a name for himself in weapons development. Think he avoided action in WWII as a result.

Wish I had the time to read some of these books. I read a fictional one about a guy in the engineers. Digging tunnels under no man's land to place bombs. Pretty hairy stuff if it's what really went on.

Originally Posted by silentC

I read a fictional one about a guy in the engineers. Digging tunnels under no man's land to place bombs. Pretty hairy stuff if it's what really went on.

That actually happened, the Brits dug tunnels under the German frontline, placed about 1,000,000lb of fireworks and lit the fuse. they reckon they heard the bang in London. It was the Battle of Messines

OK. Yeah the book is called Birdsong but it's set around the Battle of the Somme. Similar tactics applied but not as big an explosion I don't think.

Good book is Birdsong.
Well worth a read. Although I thought that the first 100 pages were a bit slow.

Yeah we could've done without all the lovey dovey stuff too

You mean when they were in the collapsed tunnel?