Thanks: 0
Likes: 0
Needs Pictures: 0
Picture(s) thanks: 0
Results 16 to 25 of 25
Thread: New use for Oxy Acetylene set?
-
12th June 2008, 07:12 PM #16Old Chippy
- Join Date
- Mar 2007
- Location
- Canberra
- Age
- 72
- Posts
- 394
Grahame knows his stuff, but on this issue I disagree: I reckon Oxy/ LPG is a a good option for many home users and CIG/Comet sell a kit that allows this combination of gases -
LP Gas Conversion Kit Part No: 308134
or a full kit
Oxy/LP Gas Part No: 308345
which has an LPG regulator, properly color-coded hoses and some other bits and pieces. To quote the Comet brochure: "the only thing you can't do is fusion weld with mild steel black wire."
I have been using my Comet 3 professional Oxy set for 30 years and for the last 25 with Oxy/LPG - based on the advice in the user manual that came with the set. The only change was that I needed an LPG nozzle for the cutter handpiece and a new oxy/LPG mixer Part No : 304116 - that's it.
I have cut steel I-beams up to 400mm x 200, various other steel sections, steel plate up to 30mm, brazed, heated, but as Graham says not welded - for that I use my 40 year old arc welder and my newer MIG.
So horses for courses and definitely no bodgying around to make things do what they shouldn't (as Grahame says gas is dangerous stuff), but there is a solid place for Oxy/LPG and if one already has a full kit of handpieces nozzles etc then a handy alternative is to kit out for Oxy/LPG.
In my case I rent a D Oxy-bottle and use one of my BBQ 9Kg bottles of LPG when I need to - using an adapter for the gas bottle fitting. Much cheaper and much safer for the average DYIer than acetylene, albeit with some compromise on what jobs can be done. I have not found that at all restrictive and I have done heaps of work as a professional and a DYIer.
-
12th June 2008 07:12 PM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Age
- 2010
- Posts
- Many
-
13th June 2008, 11:03 PM #17
Hi Bloss
I have no argument with diy metalworkers using whatever gas they choose to cut weld and heat metal
The issue I have is with people who wish to do DIY surgery on items like gauges that control and regulate volatile gas.
To understand what I mean by volatile, one really needs to experience an "event".
Visualise it if you will, the young tradesman on nightshift ,about 2 am . The long necked acetylene heating torch he was using to melt the lead that sealed bolt heads in a housing backfired and then flashed back. The molten droplets of lead found their way into the big holes on the heating rose, then ka-flaming - boom!
They tell you about this sort of thing during theory training,folks but you don't really know or understand the shocking unrestrained power of a gas explosion.
Luckily It was winter,I was rugged up in a welding jacket with a woolen jumper underneath and was wearing welding gloves and a visor. The torch shank holding the heating rose was completely melted,turned into melted spatter and the rose was found 20 metres away.
The explosion partially deafened me and left me like a stunned mullet for the remainder of the shift.
Acetylene gauges funnily enough, are bloody well designed to control acetylene and do so in a safe manner. In theory you could probaly modify one to use LPG by why would you want to? the Bourdan tube or chamber is smaller and the delivery orifice is smaller from memory. The cost of modifying could not be justified when compared to the similiar cost of an LPG regulator gauge.
In oxy cutting with LPG,I am personally acquainted with the process, having driven an LPG profile for about 4 months.The cut quality is not the same.
It will not weld steel as steel takes as it takes around 3,300 C degrees to become molten wheres the LPG ( from my dodgy memory) is about 2,700 C.
Incidentally when cutting steel only about 800 degrees C is needed for ignition.
I think if there is a solution it could come in a similar type arrangement that wood turners/woodworkers have in sharing equipment. Maybe 2 or 3 people could share in the operating costs of an oxy acetylene plant.
I just get really toey when I hear of, or see individuals ready to risk their personal safety just to save a dollar or two.
Sorry Ken my comments where never meant for you.
Have a good week end everyone
Grahame
-
14th June 2008, 11:30 AM #18Since I've already taken the cake for asking another stupid question this week, may as well top myself.
All ridiculous answers will be kept discrete.
Ken
Your question has generated a lot of responses that have enlightened many members and observers of the dangers, and I think that is a very good thing.
Please don't feel foolish. It takes guts to ask questions such as yours, when we all know that responses can be less than flattering
at times.
-
16th June 2008, 01:39 PM #19Old Chippy
- Join Date
- Mar 2007
- Location
- Canberra
- Age
- 72
- Posts
- 394
"The issue I have is with people who wish to do DIY surgery on items like gauges that control and regulate volatile gas."
Couldn't agree more . . .
And I have witnessed an acetylene explosion (in the '60s) that took part of an arm off one bloke and damaged the sight of another - and all due to some short cuts taken by someone who thought it would be OK.
As you say volatile gases are not to be played about with. Even the lack of nous when hot molten metal is involved amazes me - I have seen guys welding with rubber thongs & shorts and then wondering why they get burns! As well as chipping off hot slag without goggles etc. Some people just ask for trouble . . .
BTW - Grahame, love the tips and guidance you give, just a pity I didn't have the net 40 years ago when I started dabbling with welding & cutting (although for the first few years I had a good mentor).
-
28th June 2008, 09:00 PM #20
Fossil, I think you're right on the money there, mate.
Seeking advice from clever buggers like Grahame before a potentailly risky undertaking is a very sensible thing to do, so dont lose any sleep over having asked the question, Ken. In fact, thanks for starting the thread, as I for one have found it quite interesting and informative.
-
11th July 2008, 11:34 AM #21New Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2008
- Location
- Rowville
- Posts
- 1
Personally I'd use LPG over Acetylene for most applications on safety grounds.
Acetylene is a high explosive (it doesn't just burn above 91%, it explodes). For safety it is stored in plaster of paris soaked in acetone, the bottle pressures are slightly lower than LPG so you have a risk of damaging the regulator on LPG.
Having helped clean up (what was left of)the CIG Preston plant after an Acetylene explosion, the damage can be extensive, parts of the plant were found 2km away.
-
11th July 2008, 05:10 PM #22Senior Member
- Join Date
- Jan 2008
- Location
- Brisbane
- Posts
- 146
One of the riskiest aspects of owning oxy gear is opening the bill for the annual cylinder rental - particularly if you have a weak heart.
I just paid my bill this morning for 3 E size (one for mig) - now nearly $440 pa. before you buy any gas. Is there any real competition any more from other suppliers?
-
24th December 2008, 06:28 PM #23Pink 10EE owner
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
- Location
- near Rockhampton
- Posts
- 4,304
Another use for acetylene seems to be blowing up ATM machines...
-
24th December 2008, 08:57 PM #24
we use lpg/oxy in a standard O/A kit and have no problems.
www.carlweiss.com.au
Mobile Sawmilling & Logging Service
8" & 10" Lucas Mills, bobcat, 4wd tractor, 12 ton dozer, stihl saws.
-
4th January 2009, 10:27 PM #25machine tech.
- Join Date
- Jan 2004
- Location
- victoria/hughesdale
- Age
- 64
- Posts
- 38
Im not sure how old some of you are but who remebers the old mission impossible
series? well they always had a small oxy actlene kit.
Well I asked around and found a small kit that is mapp and oxy, not sure how hot it will get but it silver solders and I think it will braze , they say it will cut and weld . I have not tryed these yet.... When I bought it they told me the could get some more in as the main store had about 3-5 in stock early last year...
Similar Threads
-
another one for Grahame about acetylene
By durwood in forum METALWORK FORUMReplies: 10Last Post: 1st March 2008, 02:50 PM -
filling up Acetylene Oxy set
By timbo123 in forum METALWORK FORUMReplies: 8Last Post: 27th June 2007, 01:59 PM -
An odd one-Oxy acetylene gear...
By Nos4r2 in forum METALWORK FORUMReplies: 5Last Post: 16th November 2005, 07:31 AM