Thanks: 0
Likes: 0
Needs Pictures: 0
Picture(s) thanks: 0
Results 1 to 11 of 11
Thread: Pen ergonomics?
-
18th June 2007, 07:22 AM #1
Pen ergonomics?
Hi folks. You all know by now I'm sure that I'm not a turner, so I'm sorry for sticking my snout in your garden. But I do look at the beautiful pens from time to time (some amazing work) and I wondered if you all spend any time worrying about the ergonomics of the pens.
For example, the cigar pens look just right to me, but some of the others appear (only from pictures, mind you) that they might be awkward to grasp and use. This occured to me particularly because of Toni's recent medical clip pens (all very lovely, Toni--truly works of art) which struck me as perhaps a bit too thick-bodied for comfortable use. Or is that just a trick of the camera?
Can someone tell me from their experience how the different pens "feel" in use and what some of your personal favourite shapes are?
If I didn't make it clear earlier, I love your pens. This is not a complaint, just a seeking of information.Cheers,
Bob
-
18th June 2007 07:22 AM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Age
- 2010
- Posts
- Many
-
18th June 2007, 08:24 AM #2
I think about ergonomics. I don't like pens that get all fancy with little dips and hollows and end up looking as comfortable to hold as a porcupine.
But something like Toni just did I think would be comfortable. The reason being is if I recall her latest were slimelines which are a very small diameter pen. Cigar pens are much, much larger in diameter than a slimeline, if you rounded out a cigar pen like people often do with slimelines then yes, that would probably be a bit big but then again there are pen kits that are even fatter and bigger than cigar pens so I suppose it all comes down to individual preference. Cigar pens are well over a half inch in the middle, a slimeline might only be a quarter inch. So a little rounding can actually make a slimeline more comfortable to hold.
I personally love cigar pens and they way they feel but I have very big hands. If you were, or even I were, going to be writing for extended periods of time I might opt for a lighter slimeline. But then maybe that would be more uncomfortable, I dunno, who writes anymore, isn't' that what word processors are for?
-
18th June 2007, 09:30 AM #3
I'm big on a good, ergonomic pen even though I don't write for long periods of time.
I find pens are generally not long enough, especially when they have the clip on them. The clip swings down and ends up jabbing into my hand - very annoying.
Soundman and I designed a pen shape that is very very close to perfect for my hand. The only problem is that it's not long enough, but the length was decreed by the kit.
Another pen shape that might be a challenge to make, is the shape of the marking knives that Derek made for a few of us here. Now that is one heck of a comfortable tool!
https://www.woodworkforums.com/showthread.php?t=50436
cheers
WendyBox Challenge 2011 - Check out the amazing Boxes!
Twist One - Wooden Hinge/Latch/Catch/Handle
Twist Two - Found Object
Twist Three - Anything Goes
-
18th June 2007, 10:07 AM #4
When it comes to ergonomics with a pen you must remember that not everybody holds a pen the same way or for a matter the correct way to write. I was taught calligraphy so I tend to hold a pen with my thumb, fore and index finger, I have seen some grip a pen with all four fingers wrapped around a pen. As Matt has said a slimline has a 7 mm tube so if you did a straight slimline it wolud be a touch over 8mm. I am not a fan of the pronounced wasp waist style of silmline but curving it out from the nib and incorporating a cove and a fillet at the centre band and mirror that design to the top half. I have big hands so any of the larger pens feel comfortable, the only larger pen the felt awkward to me was the Panache.
Wendy hit it on the head though, in designing a shape to "suit her hand", if making pens for customers you have to look to what they want that suits their hand, if we made our pens to suit ourselves then it would be uncomfortable to others. That is why I have a selection of different styles for a customer to see what suits them. I am sure as pen crafters we do think about ergonomics, I do know that I tend sometimes to get lost in the artsy fartsy designs then Tasha May gives a reality check and I am back on path again.
Darren
-
18th June 2007, 02:48 PM #5
Pens,Shapes and Sizes
Henry Ford felt that we could eat cake so long as it fitted his recipe. I have a best friend of 55 yrs and even now can be surprised how different our likes and needs in all things can be.
Hon Bloke you have invented a new style pen at 1/4 inch when the hole in the blank is 7 mm,roughly the size of the brass insert itself is 1/4 inch.The reason we turn varying shapes is because some timbers look flat,skinny,some look dreadfull as you cut the colour and the grain in and out.When I was in Utah some several years ago I went to an education seminar with an American friend and we were all given a photocopy Xerox of a famous basketballers hand,it covered a foolscap page. My life changed that day and ever since I know I will never design a pen to fit a real lot of people all the time.Here I spent time with a young man 7 foot 6 inches tall,I am 6 foot 2 inches myself,my wife is 5 foot 2 inches,boy one size will never fit allyou want it to do.All we can do is enjoy making our way and it is amazing when you give a pen as a gift how acceptable it becomes.When you sell too much choice can kill a sale,compare apples with apples.
If you make as I mostly do slimlines with a slight hour glass shape in hundreds of cases folks say how comfortable that is.
If you want a taller pen,nothing to stop anyone using longer brasses and timber or simply make pens without clips for special places next to the computer for example.
Show us a pic of your favourite pen,let us see the variety and reasoning even if some do not make we have an opinion.
Show us your pens.
Peter
-
18th June 2007, 04:45 PM #6
I've made a few longer pens 'specially for people who've requested 'em. It's not a rare request at all. maybe the basic pen kits are designed by japanese car mfrs?
Unfortunately, for anything bar a slimline the extra tubes tend to be a bit exxy so it drives the base costs up disproportionately. Sadly, while a slimline pen lengthens nice'n'cheaply, the kit looks dicky when you make the pen thicker... and how many people do you know who like writing with knitting needles?
- Andy Mc
-
18th June 2007, 05:15 PM #7
-
18th June 2007, 09:26 PM #8
I find the slim line made according to proper specs is too narrow for me and is tiring to use, hence I make mine a bit 'meatier' at the nib end, thus reducing the degree of precision grip needed to drive it. Haven't had any complaints, but have done a couple that I think are too thick - however the older hands often liked them.
Answer - different horses for different courses!!
JD"No point getting older if you don't get smarter"
-
18th June 2007, 09:51 PM #9
Thanks for the replies. I'm learning. Horses for courses, naturally, but I now realise that the "medical" pens were slimlines and that it was actually just the camera that played my eyes.
I hold a pen the way the good sisters taught me. I'm still scared to change for fear they might come round with the ruler and smack my hand.Cheers,
Bob
-
18th June 2007, 10:26 PM #10
So if the good sisters hit the back of your hand, you would be right handed then?
-
19th June 2007, 12:47 AM #11
I would be if they'd had their way. I take your pun ( ), but actually they DID try to get me to change and I just couldn't master it so they finally gave up. The result was terrible penmanship regardless of which hand I mess it up with.
[Yes, and the bad sisters were on the left. ]Cheers,
Bob
Similar Threads
-
Simple pen marking gauge
By JDarvall in forum HAND TOOLS - UNPOWEREDReplies: 19Last Post: 30th December 2006, 08:17 PM -
Pen mechanism review.
By soundman in forum WOODTURNING - PEN TURNINGReplies: 26Last Post: 11th November 2006, 02:01 PM -
A few recent pen pics
By soundman in forum WOODTURNING - PEN TURNINGReplies: 8Last Post: 19th October 2006, 01:21 PM -
Make a Pen
By Froggie40 in forum WOODTURNING - PEN TURNINGReplies: 17Last Post: 24th September 2006, 11:54 AM -
my pen stand and latest pens
By ss_11000 in forum WOODTURNING - PEN TURNINGReplies: 11Last Post: 6th July 2006, 03:07 PM