Thread: My first box

You have done really well for your first box it lines up pretty nicely.

The fit is just a tiny bit too lose for my liking. Obviously this doesn't show on photos

Originally Posted by bassmansimon

The fit is just a tiny bit too lose for my liking. Obviously this doesn't show on photos

Shhhh don't tell anyone no one will know.

That's a great first box.
Cheers Frank.

very impressive, and nice grain match.
with recess I normally put them on the base and lip on the lid but if it's sanded well it doesn't matter. unless you make smaller thiner lids then it gives more mass to the lid!

Nice work Simon, it looks fine to me.

Excellent effort...
Jim

Looks good Simon. I like the shape.
I'm not qualified to comment on the recess but it looks fine to me.
(I'm having a go at one myself at the moment. Fingers crossed.)

Edit: My recess is in the lid.

the first is well done and it's a good design , the decision to bring the tenon on the cover or on the box is a personal decision, but in fact I prefer the cover because the box can maintain the aesthetic line without cover .. IMHO .. ..

Originally Posted by Hermit

Looks good Simon. I like the shape.
I'm not qualified to comment on the recess but it looks fine to me.
(I'm having a go at one myself at the moment. Fingers crossed.)

Edit: My recess is in the lid.

Thanks Steve good luck with it.

Originally Posted by bassmansimon

......I noticed after making it that the other boxes on this forum are made with the lip in the lid, rather than the lip in the main section of the box (as I have done). Is there some convention about how it needs to be done, or is it really just up to the individual design?

Simon

Nice looking box I've done a few in the same style myself and like them a lot - easy to grip if the lid is a tight fit.
As for the lip, I do them the same way for a couple of simple reasons - having the lip on the box gives you more volume and there's less chance of the contents getting snagged when the lid is put on . . . . and to me it just looks right!

Simnon, in the words of Jack Gibson you have "played strong, done fine".

A great box. Proportions are spot on and the shape is so easy on the eyes!!

Now be a good fella and do some more.

Hi Simon,
As far as I'm concerned, it is a personal thing, of which way you do them.
I'm for the loose lid, as a lot of people looking at your work, automatically pick up an 0bject by the lid in this case.
Lost a nice piece, years ago, when a little terrorist picked up my piece, by the lid, just got it over the edge, & the bottom dropped onto the cement floor, & the base broke off. I had $95 on it. Then I had nothing.
What does one say. Father apologized, & I thought so what. Devastated.
Of course little terrorists should not be allowed to touch things, but they do what they like most times.

Anyway Simon, I love Your Boxes, Great Wood, Great Design.

Originally Posted by issatree

Hi Simon,
As far as I'm concerned, it is a personal thing, of which way you do them.
I'm for the loose lid, as a lot of people looking at your work, automatically pick up an 0bject by the lid in this case.
Lost a nice piece, years ago, when a little terrorist picked up my piece, by the lid, just got it over the edge, & the bottom dropped onto the cement floor, & the base broke off. I had $95 on it. Then I had nothing.
What does one say. Father apologized, & I thought so what. Devastated.
Of course little terrorists should not be allowed to touch things, but they do what they like most times.

Anyway Simon, I love Your Boxes, Great Wood, Great Design.

Ah the little terrorists! Did the father pay for the box at least?