Thread: Pecan Birdhouse

Gil....what can I say except nice, nice, nice !

Thanks, Ed.
The more I look at it the more I feel the finial should be about 3mm (1/8") narrower.
A bit late for that now.

.

The more I look at it the more I feel the finial should be about 3mm (1/8") narrower.
A bit late for that now.

[/QUOTE]

yer for sure. But your probably right a bit thinner would be OK. But at the end of the day a darn nice bit of turning

Beautiful, Gil. I agree the finial could be a bit smaller. Those upper rings look challenging.

Cheers,
Joe

Gil, I like your work - way in front of me.

Someone, I can't recall who it was, told me that when you do a top like yours, you should have a straight line diminishing from the base of the top to the finial. Or a convex or concerve, but if it's going to be straight, then keep it that way.

I think your top misses by a fraction, but that's just my opinion. It's all the little details that separate good work from the great, isn't it?

So now that you've tickled our fancy, what's coming from you tomorrow?

Like the bird too, a nice touch.

Jeff

Thanks Hughie, Joe, Jefferson, and Artme.
Jefferson, you are right about the "line"....I am still learning, but I have not quite learned to spot (and fix) these little design flaws during the creation phase. There is actually another bird involved here, you just cannot see it. It is inside, about an inch+ back from the entrance and looking out (can you see it ?).

That is a nifty piece of work!

Agree with finial comments.

Originally Posted by Gil Jones

Thanks Hughie, Joe, Jefferson, and Artme.
Jefferson, you are right about the "line"....I am still learning, but I have not quite learned to spot (and fix) these little design flaws during the creation phase. There is actually another bird involved here, you just cannot see it. It is inside, about an inch+ back from the entrance and looking out (can you see it ?).

Gil, I see the little bird this time. A nice touch.

Please don't mistake my criticisms/ thoughts personally. As I said, you are streets in front of me.

Eager to see your next project too.

Jeff

Originally Posted by Gil Jones

Thanks, Ed.
The more I look at it the more I feel the finial should be about 3mm (1/8") narrower.
A bit late for that now.

right Gil...but progressing in our work is a work in progress. I learn more from the mistakes than the successes.

Jeff, your comments and/or critiques are just that…yours…and whether I agree with them or not, they are still all very helpful to me, and probably useful to others as well. I thank you, and all others, who take the time to pen (type) their ideas about my work, and that of all the other’s posted here and elsewhere.
Personally, I enjoy reading everyone’s ideas!!
Ed is quite correct in that one can learn a great deal from errors, and also from doing it right.

Hi Gil

What a little beauty!!! So very Striking

cheers
Wendy

Hi Wendy, thanks for your generous comments, and I am glad that you like the latest birdhouse.
How did your Dad like his Bee Hive?
Cheers,
Gil

Gil nice work agree with the rest finial could have been a bit longer but hey you work with what you have

I myself have yet to make even what I consider a decent finial to be proud of so I can't knock yours.

Ray

Thanks, Ray.
The solution might have been to turn the finial 3 or 4 mm thinner at its widest part, and taper out proportionally from there. Trouble is, that did not occure to me until a bit after it was glued to the birdhouse roof. Maybe next time.