Thread: Another white oak bowl

Spectacular grain but to me the proportions don't look quite right . I think it would have looked better if it had been a bit shallower,or of larger diameter , and with a smaller base , but that's just my thinking .
Ted

Originally Posted by turnerted

Spectacular grain but to me the proportions don't look quite right . I think it would have looked better if it had been a bit shallower,or of larger diameter , and with a smaller base , but that's just my thinking .
Ted

Thank you I'm getting many saying that about this piece I had been turning several shallow bowls and thought i would try something different; and I think if I had kept the sides straight to a smaller base it would have been better?

Bruce

I can see this more like a bell and I like the way this came out.

Hi splinterz25,
Beautiful piece's of timber the grain is great you must be very pleased.
I agree with Ted about the shape but as a very small amount of change can be a world of difference I feel that the transition between the curves if more defined would make a huge difference to this bowl.
Regards Rod.

Thank you guys; Yes I agree I should have done some more define curve to this piece and thought about putting it back on the lathe and doing just that?/? don't know if i will though.

Bruce

The top 1/2 of the bowl looks great for shape next time try and not make it so deep I particularly like the way you have undercut the rim on the inside which looks like it matches the outside. I would keep this bowl and put it somewhere that you can see it and as you progress you will see how you improve, I still have some of mine on the top of a unit so that I can see where I started. The turning it's self looks good and you have managed to get quite a good finish. What ever you do keep showing what you have made as it is all a learning curve and most important have fun and turn safe.