http://www.infrastructure.gov.au/roa.../BullBar_1.pdf
Quote:
extract from above link
Conclusion:
In summary, the lack of comprehensive data on bull bars in the vehicle fleet at large
and for vehicles involved in crashes precludes drawing detailed conclusions with
regard to bull bar attributable road trauma. With respect to the negative impact of bull
bars, it would appear, on balance, that bull bars present an additional risk to
pedestrians and other vulnerable road users, and also possibly to occupants of side
impacted vehicles. It is postulated that the extent of this risk is not likely to be great
because it is difficult to isolate the influence of the bull bar from other factors known
to be strongly associated with injury outcomes, such as vehicle size and speed.
Recent improvements in the design and fitting of bull bars may have reduced the risk
below that imposed by the older style bull bars used in the experimental studies and
present in many of the crash records analysed here. Issues concerned with air bag
deployment and the proper operation of crumple zones appear to have been addressed
by recent improvements in bull bar design.
This report provides no conclusive basis for opposing the use of newer-style bull bars.
There does, however, appear to be some case for considering measures to phase out
the use of older style, protruding, rigid bull bars, especially in urban areas. This
would not be a panacea for road safety. It would have a minor effect on the road toll
as a whole. Nevertheless, there is the potential to save pedestrian lives and those of
other relatively unprotected road users, such as bicyclists, as well as to reduce the risk
to both the occupants of other vehicles and to the occupants of bull bar-fitted vehicles themselves.
I'll say again;
Bullbars don't kill people... inattentive drivers kill people. (And inattentive pedestrians kill themselves.)
There is no be all and end all solution.
Ban all 4WD's from suburban streets. - So how does a family of 6 go and visit family who live in town?
Ban bullbars from suburban streets. - Are 4WD owners required to remove driving lights and bulbars every time they go into town? What about Tradesman who use their bullbars and roof racks to carry longer lengths of material?
While we're at it, ban all vehicles from suburban streets!! That way we'll dramatically reduce the road toll... oh but wait... where will all the "road safety" revenue come from?? Not to mention all jobs from the entire Motoring industry.