If I could only have one gouge
As most of you probably know, I have and regularly use bowl gouges made by most of the major brands, with just a few exceptions. With some brands, and in particular with the late comers, their offerings just replicate what is already on offer in terms of steel and flute profile, so I have not bothered with trying those unless recommended by someone whose judgement I trust.
After using most makes of BG, and in most cases constantly for many years, it is my opinion there isn't much difference between them all. You can't go too far wrong if you go with any of the big name makers.
There are of course minor differences between them. Some are better at doing some things than others and as a result our tool racks eventually become crowded.
Occasionally I look at them all and think, if I could only have one of those gouges which one would I select?
Which way would I go? Without doubt, D-way, and probably with a 5/8" BG.
Dave makes his tools from M-42 cobalt high speed steel (heat treated to 66-68 HRC, which is way up there) and they come finished to the highest level of any tool that I have used. No additional polishing is need on the flutes! They give the best finishing cut of any tool in my tool rack and I like their versatile parabolic flute profile. IMO, they have only one very minor (and then only slight) downside; the M-42 doesn't hold its cutting edge just quite as long as V10 and that only shows up with the hardest and most abrasive woods we have here in Australia. I, like most of us, don't turn enough of that hard stuff to warrant a decision on that criteria alone. Overall it comfortably wins out as the one I would select if I could only have one bowl gouge.
I bought mine back in 2012 when the A$ was on parity with the US$, but we have to find half as much again at the current exchange rate, so not a cheap option and the shipping and import tax still have to go on top of that, but that is the case with all of the turning tools that are mostly imported now.
Anyone else have a D-way that they would like to express an opinion on?
As always...