Originally Posted by
GraemeCook
Am I right to assume that you haven't glued the boards together, yet?
Yes, I have glued them and used 7 dowels in each joints. I also screwed (type 17) 3 cross members underneath (50X35 ironbark).
I made a "temporary" desk top from celery top pine in 1983 - 3 pieces 200x35 mm - and I had few tools. Sanded it with a belt sander from rough sawn, Jointed the edges with a 50 mm straight cutter bit in brand new router and straight edge. Glued it up with epoxy thickened to bottled cream consistency with sander dust (same timber). Sanded with belt sander up to 200 grit. The crappy B&D orbital sander didn't sand very well and left swirls - useless. Hence belt. Finished with Danish oil.
PVA is not very good at gap filling; epoxy is much better, and has better moisture resistance properties. Larger cracks and holes can be filled with plugs, Smaller cracks with epoxy; the trick is to get the epoxy as deep as possible into the crack - it both gllues and fills the crack. Dilute to epoxy with 50% acetone, paint over the crack, wait ten minutes and repeat; keep repeating, wicking the epoxy into the crack until it disappears.
As to the finish, I am not sure what is best on a butchering table. My understanding that butchers do not use anything on their blocks - might be worth talking to your local butcher.