Thread: Stanley S4

Googled and found this, ctrl f then type in s4 find, interesting read. The Superior Works - Patrick's Blood & Gore: Planes #1 - #8

Thanks for that Sapling, I'll probably have to buy one to see what they're like, hope they're not a dud.

I haven't used this one but have used several Sargent pressed steel planes.
The rounded edges of the sole of the plane feel funny to someone used to the traditional crisp corners of a cast grey iron plane body.
Other than that, they are thinner walled and have a flimsier feel to them than their cast siblings. This is entirely untrue as they are tougher and more indestructible.
As far as the taking of shavings goes, the ones that I have used work just fine.
In use I always thought that the pressed steel bodies "slipped" over the surface more easily, but this is a very subjective impression on my part.
Did I prefer them to the traditional iron planes - no.
The cast grey iron ones had a comforting heft and mass to them that was lacking in these pressed steel planes.
However, I'm sure that they will do the job just fine.
I would try one first before you buy, to see if you are going to like it.
Cheers
SG

Thanks SG for the info, that's about what I imagined they'd be like. I thought they might flex or twist but it sounds like a good plane to have in the toolbox. Hadn't heard of the Sargent ones . Makes me feel better hearing that as I bought one on US ebay last night for $80 in what looks like good original cond,don't know if that's a good price or not but was keen to get one .Thanks for your experience.

If you have found one in very good condition for $80, then I think that you have found a bargain. Hans Brunner says:
Stanley S4 smoothing plane

offered 1926-1942

value A$ 200

Apparently they rust faster than the regular cast grey iron variety so keep it well oiled.
The Sargents that I have used have all been block planes, but the comments still apply.
Good on you for finding a good plane at a good price.
Cheers
SG