Thanks: 0
Needs Pictures: 0
Picture(s) thanks: 0
Results 1 to 15 of 37
Thread: Box Boom Update
-
15th March 2014, 08:56 AM #1SENIOR MEMBER
- Join Date
- May 2008
- Location
- Portland, ME USA
- Posts
- 837
Box Boom Update
I plan to make a rectangular box boom for my Goat for this season.
I am drawing them into my rigs now and here is an example. I think this may be the best way to get a stiff wood boom for loose footed sails.
The dims are 2 3/8" x 1 5/8" max. Walls are 1/4" ply sides and 3/8" + top/bottom pieces of spruce.
How are these booms working for people. How light can we go?
-
15th March 2014 08:56 AM # ADSGoogle Adsense Advertisement
- Join Date
- Always
- Location
- Advertising world
- Posts
- Many
-
18th March 2014, 07:35 AM #2New Member
- Join Date
- Mar 2012
- Location
- Providence, RI, USA
- Posts
- 1
I've been thinking about doing something very similar for my build, Clint. (I'm finally getting going on it!)
I'm quite far from being a structural engineer, but I did some preliminary experimentation with a tool called the Beam Bending Applet from the Mechanical Engineering Department of the university of Utah. Try it out here: http://www.mech.utah.edu/~bamberg/re...ingApplet.html
In the end, I came up with a boom using these dimensions:
Proposed Boom height 55mm Boom width 40mm Sidewall thickness 5mm Top and bottom thickness 10mm cross section area (square mm) 1150
My experimentation has at least three flaws that I know of:
- I could not account for using a different material in part of the design, so I don't know what the effect is of using plywood instead of solid wood for the sidewalls
- 1/4" plywood is, of course, 6mm not 5mm. Not sure why I messed that up.
- Did I mention that I'm not an engineer?
With those caveats out of the way, the modelling I did suggests that a beam with these dimensions would be as stiff as the stock design under horizontal loading, about twice as stiff under vertical loading, and weigh 71% of it's weight (excluding core spacers). That is appealing, right?
It looks like our dimensions are fairly similar. I'll be very curious to see how yours goes together.
Here is a link to more info on my experiments: https://www.evernote.com/shard/s1/sh...0b532b48189485
-
18th March 2014, 08:46 AM #3
I am finally gluing up my new boom (18 months after cutting the parts!). Have the sides on now. Hope to get the top and bottom on tonight.
Mine will be 60mm tall by 50mm wide, tapering by 2 - 3 mm in the vertical at each end. That's for looks, not to save any weight. Sides, top, and bottom are all douglas fir, 10mm thick. Spacers are red cedar. I'll wrap one layer of fiberglass tape around each end. I may also wrap one layer at the downhaul and at the mid-boom block, but I haven't decided yet.
I'm not terribly concerned about the weight. The boom is not high in the boat and it is likely to be lighter than my original round boom anyway. I just want to make sure it doesn't fail catastrophically when I apply lots of downhaul.
-
18th March 2014, 10:05 AM #4Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
- Location
- NH
- Posts
- 77
It's been a long time since I took mechanics, but I seem to recall that tubing tends to be stronger than boxes?
-
19th March 2014, 01:35 AM #5Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
- Location
- NH
- Posts
- 77
I've just started to read up on how to rig the goat and see all the different variations in the boom sizes and construction techniques. The box boom looks like it would be similar to the square mast build and be a good match for the boat. Anyway, I was thinking about the tubular strength verses box shape this morning while lying in bed and thinking I don't rembered much from college. I then got to brainstorming how I might make a good looking tubular shape. My training is as a furniture maker so I usually think some sort of stave construction with or without a veneer, bent laminations or bent ply with veneer when it comes to curvy stuff. Came up with the idea below. No idea if it's been done before or if it would have any strength but it was fun thinking about. The veneer would probably be relatively inexpensive compared to clear solid stock and is usually high quality stuff. You could reuse the mold which you could shape by hand or if it was some high tech shape could have cut out on a CNC.
-
19th March 2014, 12:38 PM #6
It might be time to ping BobWes on his Box Boom experience/lessons learned: https://www.woodworkforums.com/f169/search-perfect-lug-rig-boom-goat-island-skiff-156481
Dave
StorerBoat Builder, Sailor, Enthusiast
Dave's GIS Chronicles | Dave's Lugs'l Chronicles | Dave's StorerBoat Forum Thread
-
21st March 2014, 12:03 PM #7
well, darn... I just lost my response to Cliff... let me try again...
Your proposed box-boom is similar to in size to the box booms I've built.
My first one was 45mm x 65mm, 6mm ply sides, 16mm cedar top/bottom. It weighs 2.18 kg (4.8 lbs). This is the stiffest boom I've built, too.
Subsequent booms were either lighter and not as stiff or heavier and not as stiff. My latest rendition is quite heavy (no numbers yet), built with 9mm ply sides, 12mm radiata pine top/bottom and fir plugs. It is stiffer that the first one but I am not sure that is enough to offset the weight.
For what it is worth, I plan to build a set of spars using birdsmouth construction. Because the balance lug sail specified for the Pathfinder is nearly identical to the Goat's balance lug sail, I plan to use the sail, yard and boom on both boats (I can only sail one at a time). I will need two masts. I'll share my experiences with the construction and sailing (when I get to that stage...)
Check out the wiki page Mik set up for sharing spar data and rigging info:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1...h.q5vhwde6fblr
BowWesBuilding Gardens of Fenwick, a Welsford Parthfinder
Gardens of Fenwick
Karen Ann, a Storer GIS
Goat Island Skiff - Sacramento
-
21st March 2014, 01:11 PM #8
...sorry, I meant Clint not Cliff...
Building Gardens of Fenwick, a Welsford Parthfinder
Gardens of Fenwick
Karen Ann, a Storer GIS
Goat Island Skiff - Sacramento
-
21st March 2014, 01:16 PM #9
Beaton1,
Are you familiar with birdsmouth construction?
http://www.duckworksmagazine.com/04/...uth/#remind-me
Seems that your veneer concept is along the lines of the birdsmouth method. Maybe not but it seems like it to me.Building Gardens of Fenwick, a Welsford Parthfinder
Gardens of Fenwick
Karen Ann, a Storer GIS
Goat Island Skiff - Sacramento
-
22nd March 2014, 04:56 AM #10
I just untaped and de-snotted the blank for my new boom this morning. It's going to be heavy but incredibly stiff. Hoping to round the edges and coat with epoxy this weekend. Then I can measure the weight and deflection.
-
24th March 2014, 11:11 AM #11Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2013
- Location
- NH
- Posts
- 77
I've seen examples of the birdsmouth construction but have never tried it myself. If looks pretty slick. I was thinking a veneered tubular shape would be easier to build and be similar to the plywood box shape construction except that you are making your own bent piece of plywood with all the grain running in the long direction and in a stronger cross section for a given weight or wall thickness.
-
25th March 2014, 02:44 AM #12
Or NOT!*
Makes sense though, given the dimensions you cite. Never mind the finished size, the cross section of the staves add up to about 1800 mm^2 of solid wood. The solid round boom of 40mm diameter (throw away any tapering) is only 1257 mm^2 in section.
I'm a visual learner myself, so I'm attaching (I think) a graphic illustrating the comparison.
Pauls Boom.jpg
*For the benefit of those who have not seen Paulie's Facebook post, his box boom weighs about 160% his solid round...)Dave
StorerBoat Builder, Sailor, Enthusiast
Dave's GIS Chronicles | Dave's Lugs'l Chronicles | Dave's StorerBoat Forum Thread
-
25th March 2014, 09:05 AM #13Building Gardens of Fenwick, a Welsford Parthfinder
Gardens of Fenwick
Karen Ann, a Storer GIS
Goat Island Skiff - Sacramento
-
25th March 2014, 12:54 PM #14
Yes, it is. (9.5lb/4.3kg, vs 6lb/2.3kg for the solid.) And your explanation makes perfect sense.
Although I was quite upset at first, I'm feeling more relaxed about it now. It's still not really that heavy, it won't be high up the mast, and I can always shave off a bit if I want to.
I'm going to finish it off as is and see how it works. If I find that I really don't like the weight, I'll try drilling some holes in it. And if I don't like that, I'll make another with thinner, plywood sides.
-
25th March 2014, 01:41 PM #15
That's the spirit! "I built it, I can un-build it!"
Sent from my iPhone using TapatalkDave
StorerBoat Builder, Sailor, Enthusiast
Dave's GIS Chronicles | Dave's Lugs'l Chronicles | Dave's StorerBoat Forum Thread
Similar Threads
-
Boom Crane WIP
By twoody65 in forum SCALE MODELLINGReplies: 11Last Post: 10th March 2012, 09:52 AM -
C22 Boom Arm
By Pomare in forum FESTOOL FORUMReplies: 7Last Post: 6th March 2009, 11:14 AM -
Boom Arm questions
By joez in forum FESTOOL FORUMReplies: 2Last Post: 16th October 2008, 01:02 PM -
Boom Boom
By Baz in forum WOODIES JOKESReplies: 3Last Post: 17th July 2006, 12:16 PM